Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Lethal]

The more I look into it, the more convinced I am Jeff is scum.

What is convincing you of his being scum?

 

[Lethal]

Did Jeff suggest it? Didn’t I comment something after the split?

You said it was interesting, Jeff said "wtf man." Different messages and intent in those messages.

 

[Big Man]

Being around early and pushing his own directions + going against Magic to Lynch Haza seems like town Big Man. I guess they could be scum together tho, wouldn't say he's a solid town read

would you not say this applies to Jeff as well?

 

[Xenus]

Jeff 3 - Poyser, Alco, Doddsy
EV 1 - Chloe
TKOK 1 - Magic
Magic 2 - Rugrat, Lethal
Haza 12 - Jeff, Tweet, Barry, Gambit, Big Man, Xenus, Phenom, OMB, CP, Ace, EV
OMB 2 - Smark, Haza

CP 2 - Lethal, Ace
Lethal 1 - Magic
Xenus 3 - Big Man, Tweet, Chloe
Phenom 2 - Barry, Gambit
Jeff 2 - Doddsy, CP
Gambit 1 - Phenom

Doddsy consistent on Jeff, Alco doesn't vote.
Chloe votes EV but then finishes on Xenus for D2 - why the shift?
Rugrat doesn't vote D2
I went CP, have explained why
Jeff doesn't vote D2.
Barry/Gambit voting together. BigMan/Tweet voting together. Xenus doesn't vote D2. Nom going for Gambit. OMB doesn;t vote D2. EV doesn't vote D2.

Alco, Rugrat, Jeff, Xenus, OMB, EV voted on D1 but not D2. All except Alco were involved in the phase.

Scum team: Rugrat, Jeff, Xenus, OMB & EV

Night ended at 5am my time, not sure how you want me to vote, because I voted Tweet and CP Day 2. Great idea though to just look at final wagons, makes perfect sense.

 

[Xenus]

Jeff 3 - Poyser, Alco, Doddsy
EV 1 - Chloe
TKOK 1 - Magic
Magic 2 - Rugrat, Lethal
Haza 12 - Jeff, Tweet, Barry, Gambit, Big Man, Xenus, Phenom, OMB, CP, Ace, EV
OMB 2 - Smark, Haza

CP 2 - Lethal, Ace
Lethal 1 - Magic
Xenus 3 - Big Man, Tweet, Chloe
Phenom 2 - Barry, Gambit
Jeff 2 - Doddsy, CP
Gambit 1 - Phenom

Doddsy consistent on Jeff, Alco doesn't vote.
Chloe votes EV but then finishes on Xenus for D2 - why the shift?
Rugrat doesn't vote D2
I went CP, have explained why
Jeff doesn't vote D2.
Barry/Gambit voting together. BigMan/Tweet voting together. Xenus doesn't vote D2. Nom going for Gambit. OMB doesn;t vote D2. EV doesn't vote D2.

Alco, Rugrat, Jeff, Xenus, OMB, EV voted on D1 but not D2. All except Alco were involved in the phase.

Scum team: Rugrat, Jeff, Xenus, OMB & EV

Night ended at 5am my time, not sure how you want me to vote, because I voted Tweet and CP Day 2. Great idea though to just look at final wagons, makes perfect sense.

You’re also shading the proven Actor for not voting on a Day there’s a no lynch

 

[Lethal]

Well tbf Xenus I don't have the time to go through EVERY vote like I have in the past, hence my looking at the final votes. Obviously the using "never" voted was a tad obnoxious and flawed, but maybe someone will fuck up and expose themselves?

 

[Evans]

What brings you that conclusion? Seems pretty clear to me he's a DV actor and proved it D1

You're speccing on him having an execute-mechanic, when it's quite clear he is an actor. Sure it's not a guaranteed town role, but then you consider play.





What's your PHEN0M case again?

Scum team: Rugrat, Jeff, Xenus, OMB & EV

Can you explain your thought process here? You were countering Ace about my role and looking at my play - you didn't give any thoughts, I'd imagine if you felt I was scum you'd be disagreeing with Ace about my play being townie.

How have you ended up with me being scum based off of me only voting on one wagon when you have even stated how clear my role is?

 

[Xenus]

Well tbf Xenus I don't have the time to go through EVERY vote like I have in the past, hence my looking at the final votes. Obviously the using "never" voted was a tad obnoxious and flawed, but maybe someone will fuck up and expose themselves?

It’s a good job I know you’re town

 

[Lethal]

Yeah I thought I had something E-V and botched it. This why I don't like applying my usual bite anymore.

But something has to be done to gain some traction.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Why are you lying lethal, I never said that about survivor

 

[NotBrutus]

Bold I lean town on. Scum would be in the other 6 names. Jeff, Tweet, Big Man, Phenom, CP, Ace. Starting with town reads as I feel more confident in those

I mean I had my vote on Phenom for hours before it (Phenom didn't notice this either).

Scum: Phenom. Not got many others. Town reads have been easier for me this game:

Evans, Lethal, Barry, Smark, TKOK, OMB, Xenus, Chloe aka Flay are my town reads with Evans, Lethal, Smark and Chloe being the strong ones

The first part I don't remember saying. That sounds like something CP said I think. Phenom has been trying but his day 2 play feels scummy as hell (pushing Posyer/Magic V2 still and the vote on me)

The only scummy thing from phenom is the "lynch anyone but flay" post. Only because he doesn't even seem to think he is town so weird post to make

Sent from my SM-A202F using Tapatalk

If this is the reason, it is as weak as my Flay stuff in hindsight because Poyser actually had to rep out and was busy

(in response to Phenom)

Ok, actually looking back on your posts, I was wrong, and your story checks out. You’re good in my book, dude

 

[Smart Marx]

Why are you lying lethal, I never said that about survivor

Yeah, I asked him if he was sure cuz I think I brought it.

 

[Tweet]

Want to quote it for me I don't remember it

I made a reads list during n1 and below that I said why I feel bad about you. I made a post covering Lethal being similar to MTG, and that same post also had me feeling weird about Alco cause of colourgate. You came in very shortly after that post and reduced it to colourgate exclusively and we never got to talk about Lethal. So that's why I thought Lethal and you might be a team. And soon after that you began talking about infolynching me which nobody ever took seriously but it's still a massively thing to suggest, especially since it didn't even involve much talking to me or pushing me or regard any potential claim I might have. I already admitted this is partly OMGUS from my side but that's why I currently am not a fan of you.

Okay this is better and makes sense - thank you for explaining. (See I can be too)

On the info lynch however, CP asked who we would lynch out of everyone right now (end of D1) and I said you because I thought we would get the most out of your interaction. I even specifically said to CP that it’s not because I felt you were scum, but because I felt we would get the most information from your flip based on the interaction. I feel you’ve taken that way too personally and that’s another reason to feel you’re overreacting. I’m willing to reevaluate rather than tunnel.

unvote

I’m off to bed anyway now and won’t be back before EOD as it’s like 6am my time. I think I’m going to have to re-evaluate everything when I wake up because my head is all over the place. I will look at everything again.

 

[Tweet]

Odo Hosting History:

Final Fantasy - no census
NFL - no census
Metal Gear - no census
Yu-Gi-Oh - no census
Persona 5 - no census
Ace Attorney - no census (had an actor with DV powers though, it was Barry fwiw)
Three Kingdoms - no census
WWE Jobbers - no census
Nintendo - no census

So I think it really random that suddenly we now have a census in the game that is claimed by an erratic player. Someone even said Odo is on record saying he HATES the role, so I doubt he puts it in. Yeah Lethal, don't try and outguess the host, but the history speaks for itself. He was all happy to be the lynch (OMB), then said not to lynch him. Barry was keen to prove his legitimacy (bussing?) and then it's suddenly dropped on D2.

Food for thought

Intredasting

I wasn't too huge a fan of pushing OMB for this claim of his alone but I think we also gotta ask ourselves how long we really wanna postpone figuring him out for. Cause since it's OMB I don't expect to gain a play-based read of him anytime soon and his lynch me - don't lynch me antics have also been strange.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Yeah, I asked him if he was sure cuz I think I brought it.

gambit did, actually, easily checkable if you search survivor. only 3 mentions of it.