You're speccing on him having an execute-mechanic, when it's quite clear he is an actor. Sure it's not a guaranteed town role, but then you consider play.
What's your PHEN0M case again?
General scummy play. There isn't honestly a ton to go on right now other than reading people's play as we are yet to have a scum flip. But I have found his posting to be pretty scummy recently.
See below:
Unvote
Just won’t make my own reads anymore and sheep. Let me know who to vote.
This was weak tea. Reeks of fake outrage and these sorts of posts inevitably end with players being coddled and, as we've seen with Smark in this game, town read - so it is a pretty easy out.
I was blah earlier on this morning and said I’d vote wherever and Doddsy politely asked at the time so i indulged him.
Quoting this post but the whole idea of doing this was extremely lazy and an easy way to not commit to a read on someone.
I’ll ask you a hypothetical, what if i have reason that isn’t known to everyone to continue to pursue my read?
My CP read is going to be called stupid, but I 100% agree with his self assessment about not killing Magic night 1 if he’s scum. He also has been a bit defensive this day phase, i don’t liken reactive/agressive CP to scum CP. Feel like he calmly tries to get pressure off of himself.
How strong is the reason?
It's not stupid because I agree HE wouldn't make the decision to make the kill on Magic. However sometimes other teammates make it. I remember a game where CP was busy so he didn't make kill choices or even discussed them.
This exchange immediately interested me particularly since Gambit is my strongest town read and has been actively posting this sort of stuff to try get stuff going, so accusing him of fishing and trying to shut down that discussion so abruptly is a bit iffy.
Picked a nice easy, pushable target, the guy who had the one scum read on a guy with 4 posts and reps out. Yet I’m the lazy one
Accusing Gambit of being lazy again. This certainly isn't the case, and scum reading Poyser/Magicv2 when he did really did seem based on nothing.
If Phenom were to have additional info on Poyser/Magicv2 he would be cognizant that his vote/scumlean looks weird without his own inside knowledge. So getting funny with Gambit for identifying this feels... questionable.
My reads are the same, literally nothing happened yesterday. How that’s possible with 20 people, not exactly sure but there seems to be some scared cowardice going on for sure with the lack of urgency to get things done.
While I do kind of get that nothing happened yesterday, this continues in the vain of Phenom refusing to commit to anything - as previously highlighted in his following Barry's vote, hinting but not claiming info on Poyser/MagicV2, fake outrage = reason to coast.
I want to read back on Jeff as he's a town lean for me and he seems normal but I was pretty confused around the whole Lethals post mistake and why it made Jeff look bad lol.
Alco I'm liking so far, he's had his own opinions much like when he pushed Chris in Star Wars.
Ace though I'm not 100% sure on.
This post specifically - OMB is a decent lynch target and we get guaranteed useful info, but instead ended up voting you and disappearing for the night lol. WIFOM about disappearing but doesn't feel right.
I wasn't a huge fan of out of nowhere posting his defence on the Haza wagon again.
Then finally, this was super weird as well:
Tries to draw suspicion around me leaving null players off my reads list, I answer it and then suddenly "oh yeah I didn't even read your post lol, here's a town read"
Regarding your point on my CP vote, I believe the same people others have been saying recently re OMB - that lynching him was better than no lynching on D1 but now that we're deep, testing the Census doesn't offer
enough value - particularly given we're yet to hit scum. You're right that me disappearing may look bad but honestly I just didn't come online last night lol.
My reposting of my Haza defence has been explained. I already showed how multiple people had taken individual quotes out of context so rather than continually deal with the drips of out of context single-quotes, I wanted to make my position clear.
Re: list, I wasn't trying to draw suspicion. I genuinely wanted to know why I wasn't on your list. It really shouldn't surprise you that the first thing I noticed with your list is that I wasn't on it.
There's no obvious reason scum would leave certain people off their list - if anything, they'd be more inclined to list everyone to avoid unwanted attention.
