Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Ace]

This is fair, but why did Jeff do what he did yesterday. I don't understand the rationale there.

I don't either. And I don't think Lethal is scum fwiw; I think he genuinely missed the deadline. But I'm just going through the permutations.

 

[Evans]

I've not long woken up, so excuse me for being thick - I haven't had a coffee yet.

I can understand the thought process behind Jeff isn't stupid enough to lie about his report. I just think it's a fairly easy reach to say "well he was redirected" when Chloe flipped as town.

I think Lethal "forgetting" to shoot his supercop shop stinks to high heavens. Smark is right in saying that if Jeff was scum with Lethal then the best (and only) play would be to say Jeff came back as town again.

 

[Evans]

It could be a genuine mistake it just feels too coincidental lol

 

[Kross Rhodes]

But no because if Jeff flips scum at any point then Lethal is insta-scum off the back of a fake town report.

And he had to investigate Jeff tonight for obv reasons.

Why would Jeff flip after two guaranteed town reads?

 

[Ace]

Also important:

CP can you still cure people from poison?

 

[Kross Rhodes]

It could be a genuine mistake it just feels too coincidental lol

I'm thinking, probably, cuz the play is botched to all hell if not.

 

[Ace]

Why would Jeff flip after two guaranteed town reads?

If people don't trust Lethal.

I agree, it's unlikely. My point is regardless of permutations, Jeff looks like scum with the sole exception being if he was roleblocked.

Which admittedly is a larger chance than I think many are giving credence. But I don't think we can hold off based on that chance.

 

[Evans]

Also important:

CP can you still cure people from poison?

If he can, I'd rather him save the shot tbh. Rugrat is inactive and the host has nearly double his posts. We're closing in on POE, let it happen IMO.

More important players to save with the healing shots.

 

[Kross Rhodes]

13 minutes. I missed by 13 minutes. Was catching up on the days events and realised too late.

Will be pissed if my target is scum too

Did you have any doubts you've be using it on Jeff, though?

 

[Evans]

If he's got a decent amount - then sure, but if it's like 1-2 shot, then no

 

[Ace]

If he can, I'd rather him save the shot tbh. Rugrat is inactive and the host has nearly double his posts. We're closing in on POE, let it happen IMO.

More important players to save with the healing shots.

I highly doubt 3P has unlimited poison shots tho. That would surely be OP.

 

[Lethal]

Did you have any doubts you've be using it on Jeff, though?

100% was going to be on Jeff to settle it once and for all.

Absolutely filthy with myself that I didn't check in earlier. I'm getting that fucking app for next game so I can check-in on my phone.

I'm going to consider this:

a) Jeff was copped Asgard
b) Does scum Jeff stick his neck out so much to get Chloe lynched of all people, esp. with the HEL mechanic in play. it's an auto lynch possibility? Most probably not, Jeff is all about them points and rankings. I still see "go beat your wife" in my discord inbox lol

 

[Evans]

I highly doubt 3P has unlimited poison shots tho. That would surely be OP.

We've had 2 poisonings from 2 different players at this rate. N0m is dead and Rugrat has now become poisoned. Likelyhood is that it's an indy with poisoning abilities now - would you agree? Depending how many shots CP has and if he can even still use the role, I think we should use caution before rushing in to save an inactive and potentially being a detriment to guaranteed/very likely town players who have got us this far.

I didn't suggest they'd have unlimited shots either, where has that come from?

 

[Lethal]

Also, Day 4 and Rugrat is still amongst us with a grand ~25 posts. Seriously?

 

[Evans]

100% was going to be on Jeff to settle it once and for all.

Absolutely filthy with myself that I didn't check in earlier. I'm getting that fucking app for next game so I can check-in on my phone.

I'm going to consider this:

a) Jeff was copped Asgard
b) Does scum Jeff stick his neck out so much to get Chloe lynched of all people, esp. with the HEL mechanic in play. it's an auto lynch possibility? Most probably not, Jeff is all about them points and rankings. I still see "go beat your wife" in my discord inbox lol

If we're not lynching Jeff, we're lynching Magic. His behaviour is WAY too obvious that he's not town and he's just coasting now until he's in a position to win.