No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

Wow. I honestly didn’t expect that to end up being town and town. There were so many arguments to be made against both of them.

the way omb used his role was super scummy ya, and now in hindsight, just a big error on his part. We had John almost lynched, why waste your role and make yourself look bad? sucks because in retrospect I bet from his pov he was helping.

John had so many flags, I'll take some responsibility for that though, I did push it

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Wow. I honestly didn’t expect that to end up being town and town. There were so many arguments to be made against both of them.

Yea. I was in the 80-90% sure on McHenry. He did everything that I was told scummers do when I started playing, even bailing out and not claiming after he realized he was gonna get voted out.

Gacy, I had a scum lean on. Not quite as strong as JM, but still felt good. So far, Juice is playing a fucking hell of a game. She read both of those spot on, even if I didn't agree with how she got there.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

the way omb used his role was super scummy ya, and now in hindsight, just a big error on his part. We had John almost lynched, why waste your role and make yourself look bad? sucks because in retrospect I bet from his pov he was helping.

John had so many flags, I'll take some responsibility for that though, I did push it

Yea. I actually asked him when he announced the duel "You're really going to duel somebody we have 6/10 votes on?!" Seemed like such a scummy move to try to off a team mate who was dead in the water.

Several of us thought John was scum. Fuck, I had an entire post outlining my reasoning on it.

 

[Mandalorian]

Yea. I was in the 80-90% sure on McHenry. He did everything that I was told scummers do when I started playing, even bailing out and not claiming after he realized he was gonna get voted out.

Gacy, I had a scum lean on. Not quite as strong as JM, but still felt good. So far, Juice is playing a fucking hell of a game. She read both of those spot on, even if I didn't agree with how she got there.

Is it possible Juice is working with TMI? Like there was so many flags against them both and she had them both as null on her reads list?

Not to mention she was late on the vote. I believe 9 was actually the majority due to Pein not being here anymore and us dropping down to 17.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Is it possible Juice is working with TMI? Like there was so many flags against them both and she had them both as null on her reads list?

Not to mention she was late on the vote. I believe 9 was actually the majority due to Pein not being here anymore and us dropping down to 17.

at this point I have to put that on the table yeah, I did call her two comments about "if they all flip town ill be sad" as possibly performative.

 

[Sister Abigail]

You say "filler" but:

- offered thoughts re: myself and Jeff over the Sky vote
- calls out Sky for not asking you a question directly
- comments on your theory post giving 3rd option as most likely
- moves to liking Jeff after initially having him as null

So that's not filler at all, he's offered input to the game and isn't looking like 'coasting' here at all.

@Sister Abigail thoughts?

What are you asking me exactly? While filler might be too harsh for Barry, I don't think he's played a smart game so far and I'm struggling seeing his motivation. I'm confused, though. Aren't you scum reading Barry? Isn't Juice? Where's the conflict?

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Is it possible Juice is working with TMI? Like there was so many flags against them both and she had them both as null on her reads list?

Not to mention she was late on the vote. I believe 9 was actually the majority due to Pein not being here anymore and us dropping down to 17.

It's possible, but IDK. I'm starting to think she's just genuiely been making some great reads. BUT, I'm concerned about her lateness to the vote, and her reasoning for McHenry's town read. I'd put her on the slightest town read that I can make of someone.

 

[CakeWalker]

A lot of false flags on them really.

"Weaker player" like myself - are often accused of being scummy. When really its easier just bad play or just an alternative way of playing.
I'm also not moving Jeff off a neutral status - but. If I had proposes John instead of Jeff - I don't think McHenry would have even been the lynch at all.

Mafia are opportunistic and a lot of townie are lazy in votes and care more about surviving longer than taking risks imo

 

[Sister Abigail]

@Sister Abigail from earlier when the Jeff putting a fellow wolf out was considered. you, uh, liked the post to...

Which post is that? If it was about Jeff being able to bus a mate, he absolutely could.

 

[Mandalorian]

It's possible, but IDK. I'm starting to think she's just genuiely been making some great reads. BUT, I'm concerned about her lateness to the vote, and her reasoning for McHenry's town read. I'd put her on the slightest town read that I can make of someone.

Where did she read McHenry as town?

The most recent reads list I saw her she had him as null?

 

[Pendex]

@Sister Abigail Am I correct in saying you had Grimch in your "sus" list?

 

[Sister Abigail]

@Sister Abigail Am I correct in saying you had Grimch in your "sus" list?

Yeah Barry has been a wolf lean since my first reads list. Pretty sure he was one of the people I isoed early and gave some thoughts on him.

 

[CakeWalker]

someone should do an iso/dossier - on everything I said about John McHenry really. And it can't be me - obviously.

Hopefully once you read it back - you will realize why Juice is better than Sauce

 

[Sister Abigail]

I think I did Juice, Barry, and Gacy early. Then I did one on John.

 

[Pendex]

Yeah Barry has been a wolf lean since my first reads list. Pretty sure he was one of the people I isoed early and gave some thoughts on him.

Are you sure about that? Because I recall our discussion earlier and you seemed to be leaning the other way.