No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Ekkologix]

Because I felt like it and shot him on a gut feeling of a whim.

In hindsight, was it a smart shot? No. Could it still provide useful results wrt reactions and the like? Yes. Shooting T-Pein isn't a net negative even if we lose a townie. You can still have a baseline to work with, especially if John flips scum

what useful results u got from it?

u cuda saved the shot for later I don't get why use it just for a feeling. id never just shoot like that

 

[CakeWalker]

Barry's pushing for me to be next lynch after John - that list looks like a mafia's day lynch wish list. So more accomplished players - can be killed at night.

 

[CakeWalker]

Yeah John flipping scum gives us a baseline for Juice and Gacy as well. Mixed with T-Pein's flip as town and Juice not really explaining her reads on him very well, I'd say the shot wasn't a total waste.

I like the pool of John, Juice, Gacy, and N0M atm.

Explains - how it gives us a baseline.

This is just more waffle from you Barry. You've got to go today.

 

[Mandalorian]

Anyway, I’m off to bed. I think that McHenry is the right way to go still and him hinting a claim that would put a target on his back doesn’t cut it for me as enough of a reason to hold off on the lynch. If the claim is enough to get him in mafia’s sights then it would be enough to make us consider other options whilst we still have the time.

 

[Mandalorian]

Barry's pushing for me to be next lynch after John - that list looks like a mafia's day lynch wish list. So more accomplished players - can be killed at night.

I thought he was saying Phenom next?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

what useful results u got from it?

u cuda saved the shot for later I don't get why use it just for a feeling. id never just shoot like that

Well we got Juice desperate for me to die despite all other discussion. We also are able to gauge reactions and how people would play around that down the line. So I'm looking optimistically rather than thinking it's a waste. It also took out a potential mislynch by scum down the line. So yeah.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I thought he was saying Phenom next?

Correct lmfao

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I thought he was saying Phenom next?

Same

 

[Ekkologix]

Explains - how it gives us a baseline.

This is just more waffle from you Barry. You've got to go today.

barry never had to claim the shot if he's scum tho

 

[B01]

Vote: John McHenry

I'm headed back to bed for the night. Need to actually go to work to get paid. Night everyone

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Anyway, I’m off to bed. I think that McHenry is the right way to go still and him hinting a claim that would put a target on his back doesn’t cut it for me as enough of a reason to hold off on the lynch. If the claim is enough to get him in mafia’s sights then it would be enough to make us consider other options whilst we still have the time.

Based on my math, we need five more votes and 13 hours. Plenty of time to be sure, but yea, he’s done enough to get all my attention presently.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Turned out it wasn't a waste. Pain was already a suspect, tunneled the shit out of Sky, and despite the idea of losing a townie being a "net negative" I look at it as a net positive because his style of play and lack of cooperation with some people would have only made more people want to vote him.

I look at it overall as a positive. That role would have done him no favors if he was forced to claim tbh.

What on earth are you talking about? You literally just murdered a townie in cold blood and you don't care? Maybe Tpein isn't helpful to you, but I have worked well with him in lots of games and think it's an overall NEGATIVE that Tpein is dead. Barry, what the fuck is this logic?

 

[Wangman Page]

Just got home reading through now.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

 

[CakeWalker]

What on earth are you talking about? You literally just murdered a townie in cold blood and you don't care? Maybe Tpein isn't helpful to you, but I have worked well with him in lots of games and think it's an overall NEGATIVE that Tpein is dead. Barry, what the fuck is this logic?

I am glad someone else can see this madness.

 

[Ekkologix]

Well we got Juice desperate for me to die despite all other discussion. We also are able to gauge reactions and how people would play around that down the line. So I'm looking optimistically rather than thinking it's a waste. It also took out a potential mislynch by scum down the line. So yeah.

i dont really agree. and specially so if tpein was suspecting you.