No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Ekkologix]

welcome to my logic.

well that usage is super bad id imagine atleasta summate wud tell barry to use it in another order

its all wifom

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I didn't think it was something to claim. My goal was to be a NK target as opposed to a power role

I can see that point of view, but the earlier you claim it, the better overall it is for town. With the Innocent Child, there's zero reason to claim it early since all you need to do is just reveal yourself publicly when it comes down to it and confirm yourself.

Miller and Beloved Princess are two roles that generally need to be claimed early otherwise they cause issues just like this.

It also heavily depends on if the beloved princess skips day phase through death period or if it's conditional, and as you've already pointed out. A total death Beloved Princess is a role that nobody wants out in the open because it causes all sorts of issues regardless for town. It's the definition of a negative utility for town.

 

[CakeWalker]

TOWN:
Tommy Bedlam
Mandalorian
Turanga Leela
Sky

TOWN LEAN:
Cereal Killer
PHEN0M
Ekkologix
People's Wang
Shade

A DEGREE OF GREEN:
Sister Abigail

NEUTRAL:
Silent Bite
Pendex

MAFIA LEAN:
50/50 - Baldrick

MAFIA:
The Grimch

 

[Sky]

I can see that point of view, but the earlier you claim it, the better overall it is for town. With the Innocent Child, there's zero reason to claim it early since all you need to do is just reveal yourself publicly when it comes down to it and confirm yourself.

Miller and Beloved Princess are two roles that generally need to be claimed early otherwise they cause issues just like this.

It also heavily depends on if the beloved princess skips day phase through death period or if it's conditional, and as you've already pointed out. A total death Beloved Princess is a role that nobody wants out in the open because it causes all sorts of issues regardless for town. It's the definition of a negative utility for town.

This would have been a great time to save your daykill shot btw

 

[Pendex]

Just saw the claim - I kind of hate how the scum team have the upper hand in terms of leverage here after D1. Does it skip a day if he gets killed too? Might be worthwhile.

 

[Sky]

Vote Barry

Sticking back with this

 

[Sky]

Just saw the claim - I kind of hate how the scum team have the upper hand in terms of leverage here after D1. Does it skip a day if he gets killed too? Might be worthwhile.

Typical version doesn't fire if killed by another means, because that would be bastard.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

well that usage is super bad id imagine atleasta summate wud tell barry to use it in another order

its all wifom

i would say too...yes scum are coward but if barry was gonna take a sacrifice daykill attempt and potentially fall on his sword for it...if im on his team, he aint wasting that shot on tpein lol. id shoot me, you, mando etc you know what i mean

 

[Bobby Barrows]

This would have been a great time to save your daykill shot btw

CAPTAIN HINDSIGHT!!!

Doesn't do anything to help in the now! Just talks about mistakes.

 

[Ekkologix]

i think wang can be town

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Ugh. Unvote Shade

I think he's full of shit, but we can't drop 5 townies and lose an extra day phase. Me dropping my vote should put us 5 votes shy of a potentially game altering mislynch.

 

[Pendex]

Typical version doesn't fire if killed by another means, because that would be bastard.

Good to know.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

This would have been a great time to save your daykill shot btw

But I also like how you aren't taking into consideration that perhaps the daykill is a counter to this fake claim, eh?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Regardless, I've still got my vote on Baldrick lel

 

[Canadian Dragon]

we got a million hours left ya?