Nintendo Mafia - Game Thread

[Bobby Barrows]

Why do you suspect I'm scum if Tweets is scum?

Excellent question.

It all comes down to agency and bussing.

All three of you have things that sort of ring alarms in my head.

OMB has been nudging and prodding people for directions starting with both me and Mitch. It reads to me as, "I'm not confident in pushing these mislynches by myself and want other townies to do the work for me so I can agree with them and say I had the same thoughts". He hasn't voted once all day despite there being plenty of incentives to do so when he was on and with all he's saying "Would vote Grim, would vote Tweet". You see what I'm seeing?

The argument for you is admittedly the weakest but I feel your push on me contains a real lack of sincerity in its intent. You see me as an easy mislynch and Tbf, I'm not going to deny that I am. With Tweet pinning himself into a corner and you locking your vote on me, all you can do is push people in that direction to get a claim without having to do any dirty work. Feels like a bus to me.

Big Man is also admittedly a weak argument but I feel he's willing to get me mislynched because, again, I'm an easy mislynch, and my lynching doesn't hurt his standing with the rest of the players. He's free to just push for my mislynch with impunity because he can.

Mind you, this **all** is dependent on Tweet flipping scum. If it doesn't then the theory falls apart.

 

[Roy Mustang]

Fair Jeff. I'm going to leave my vote here for now Unvote Vote: Barry . Feel more sure on Barry

You'd think if I wanted to distance and look good off your lynch I'd be a bit more decisive about my read on you than this

This is a fair point. Tweet isn't a weak player (BUT HE CAN'T DELIVER THE GOODS) so surely he would be more hard on you if that theory was true.

Except you doing that would make it such an obvious distancing tactic. You're making yourself sound reasonable because it helps you blend in better than if you were to say, "Oh I'm 100% Barry is town". Make no mistake, I'm town, but your very hastily put together switching of reads on me is the heart of the matter.

Counter point. Mafia is about using the limited infomation to make reads. Now new info comes up surely Tweet could change his read?

Luigi & Mario make sense as mason too.

I might be willing to vote Tweetum as I am little sussy of him

May I ask why ?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Ninja'd by OMB but that feels like a vote he has to make.

 

[Tweet]

Guessing the mason claim from mitch does fuck all. Why did you think Sky might be the mason when asking the mason to claim? I can't see the logic there from a town or scum mason.

Cause immediately saying something that the mason partner would never say is precisely the sort of transparent play I'd expect out of her.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Fair Jeff. I'm going to leave my vote here for now Unvote Vote: Barry . Feel more sure on Barry



This is a fair point. Tweet isn't a weak player (BUT HE CAN'T DELIVER THE GOODS) so surely he would be more hard on you if that theory was true.



Counter point. Mafia is about using the limited infomation to make reads. Now new info comes up surely Tweet could change his read?



May I ask why ?

I'm willing to concede that point if only because it's a fantastic point. But it's also D1 and being so headstrong about reads on D1 is you know?

 

[RDK]

Excellent question.

It all comes down to agency and bussing.

All three of you have things that sort of ring alarms in my head.

OMB has been nudging and prodding people for directions starting with both me and Mitch. It reads to me as, "I'm not confident in pushing these mislynches by myself and want other townies to do the work for me so I can agree with them and say I had the same thoughts". He hasn't voted once all day despite there being plenty of incentives to do so when he was on and with all he's saying "Would vote Grim, would vote Tweet". You see what I'm seeing?

The argument for you is admittedly the weakest but I feel your push on me contains a real lack of sincerity in its intent. You see me as an easy mislynch and Tbf, I'm not going to deny that I am. With Tweet pinning himself into a corner and you locking your vote on me, all you can do is push people in that direction to get a claim without having to do any dirty work. Feels like a bus to me.

Big Man is also admittedly a weak argument but I feel he's willing to get me mislynched because, again, I'm an easy mislynch, and my lynching doesn't hurt his standing with the rest of the players. He's free to just push for my mislynch with impunity because he can.

Mind you, this **all** is dependent on Tweet flipping scum. If it doesn't then the theory falls apart.

I feel that I need to hang my hat on a lynch early here and you are the one I feel best about on this day. You being roleless makes me feel more relaxed about locking my vote too. Sorry if you're town and get lynched

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Also FWIW,

My town leans atm are Jeff, Sky, and I'll say Rugrat gets a town lean as well.

 

[Daddy Deville]

Ninja'd by OMB but that feels like a vote he has to make.

I have to make? Ill do whatever I want im town if someone feels mafia to me ill vote.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I feel that I need to hang my hat on a lynch early here and you are the one I feel best about on this day. You being roleless makes me feel more relaxed about locking my vote too. Sorry if you're town and get lynched

Understandable.

In the interest of fairness, if Tweet is town, I feel a bit less sure on you.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I have to make? Ill do whatever I want im town if someone feels mafia to me ill vote.

So why didn't you vote me when you said you felt I was mafia

 

[Canadian Dragon]

can we get a vote count @Odo

 

[Daddy Deville]

So why didn't you vote me when you said you felt I was mafia

I said I felt one of you or Chris were maf I more dont buy your claim as VT more then anything

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I said I felt one of you or Chris were maf I more dont buy your claim as VT more then anything

Again, so why didn't you vote me once in all of this?

 

[Chris]

I said I felt one of you or Chris were maf I more dont buy your claim as VT more then anything

Are you all caught up on the thread rn? Who do you think is most likely scum out of everyone so far?

 

[Daddy Deville]

Again, so why didn't you vote me once in all of this?

I told you way like damn I dont kmow what you are trying to get.