Sky 2 - Gambit, Magic
Mitch 3- Alco, Rugrat, Tweet
Barry 7 - Haza, Chris, Big Man, Mitch, OMB, Jeff, Phenom
OMB 1 - Barry
i also have jeff and chris as town.
so that would leave mitch and big man and like i say every god damn time, there's not going to be zero scum on a two wagon.
out of those two, mitch fits best. doesn't mean big man cant be scum too, but mitch just stands out.
gambit also unlikely paired with sky.
Nintendo Mafia Day 2
OMB 9 - Big Man, Gambit, Chris, Haza, Rugrat, Lethal, Alco, Jeff, Mitch
this is a lot more messy, but let's go with jeff/chris as town.
i think gambit is also town if sky is scum.
so that leaves alco/lethal/big man/rugrat.
i kinda agree that big man's gambit as scum on day 2 is unlikely. i wont say he's not scum for it as ive seen some dumber shit and im not going down that route anymore, but less likely.
ive liked most of the thoughts alco has given so that leaves lethal and rugrat. rugrat is ???, i do think he could be scum.
i also think lethal is scum. lethal's interactions with sky have been weird. this is the only game he's not jumping to lynch her when everyone else does. lethal isnt the type to reform, he legitimately cant help but go after her endlessly and after every game and yet didnt this game. have they even really interacted this game? like that's glaringly unusual. again this isn't based on sky being scum with lethal, even if she happens to be town lethal just flat out not wanting to lynch her rubs me the wrong way because he just ALWAYS defaults to it and yet the one game others are down he's opposing it.
so let's go with jeff/chris/alco as town for now. gambit is conditional. i think tweet is likely town too tbh, but idk ill see.
i think there's a lot of scum in mitch(omb)/sky/lethal/rugrat and roughly that's the order of scumminess from what ive read so far.