I think you described why WWE is failing with its fans, lol. In all honesty, I feel you on the star ratings, the Firing Squad parts, and that it feels like a straight sport and the stories/feuds feel right, or natural as you put it. So would you say Omega is the NJPW Roman or Brock then, lol?
This should be fun... for entertainment purposes only...
B Block:
Kenny Omega: AJ Styles (Natural champ, star rating ace, guy you simply believe is the best guy in the company)
Tetsuya Naito: Seth Rollins (Stellar combo offense, very reliable wrestler who sometimes steps up and gives you amazing stuff)
Kota Ibushi: Cedric Alexander (Known for his high-flying acumen, but is a jack of all trades. Still hard to beat in a striking battle or on the mat)
SANADA: Cesaro (Sneakily athletic, tough, jack of all trades guy who's an amazing "base" and counter-wrestler who works great with everyone)
Zach Sabre, Jr: Daniel Bryan (Closest thing WWE has to a submission ace)
Tomohiro Ishii: Samoa Joe (There's no WWE comparison to Ishii lol, so may as well pick the big dude who can take a beating and get up and chop you to fuck)
Hirooki Goto: Bobby Lashley (Really tough dude who can overpower you and always feels like he's just on the verge of greatness, but missing something)
Toru Yano: No Way Jose (Just pick the comedy guy on the roster lol. Jose is secretly a powerhouse, much like Yano's amateur background)
Juice Robinson: Rusev (Lovable dork with infectious charisma. Gets just enough wins to make us mark out whenever the guy gets one)
Tama Tonga: Jey Uso (Great athlete, islander tag team ace, charismatic as hell)
A Block:
Hiroshi Tanahashi: John Cena (Seems too easy. The old ace who's kayfabe 90% of what he used to be, but Tanahashi's selling is so damn good.)
Kazuchika Okada: Roman Reigns (Or at least, what Roman Reigns should be. The Balloonmaker having his reign as The Guy, overstepping the last guy fairly easily, always winning quality matches and then going into a crisis when he doesn't win... Yeah.)
EVIL: Sheamus (The more of a hoss you put this guy against, the better his matches are. Loves to fight, loves to take damage, loves to step up and fight back)
Jay White: Shinsuke Nakamura (The heel Nak who's out here screwing around and ball-shotting people because he can, even if he's good enough to win without it)
Minoru Suzuki.. Not even gonna try lol
Bad Luck Fale: Kevin Owens (Dangerous big man who kayfabe doesn't care if he gets DQ'ed if he hurts someone)
Michael Elgin: Braun Strowman (Scary strong big lug who always seems like a tough out because while he can be outsmarted, he can wreck you in a snap)
Togi Makabe: Kane (The old veteran is far away from his main event days but still delivers powerful offense)
Hangman Page: Finn Balor (All the "potential" in the world but isn't on the level of the other top guys)
YOSHI-HASHI: Randy Orton (Spectacular veteran who's great at timing and pacing once every blue moon when he gives a damn)