MTG Mafia, Angels vs. Enemies - Game Thread

[Evans]

So why'd scum shoot CP last night which would have to be true for Magic to be scum? Unless we have ANOTHER protection role.

You said it could have been to set up a mislynch of people pushing CP right? Like who exactly

Because Magic is scum and shooting himself makes no sense? Everyone knew CP was riding high on POE. Magic even backed my reasoning for shooting CP not being on Jeff's wagon or OMB's lol.

People on CP were Lethal, me and Banez. Lethal died from lynch so obvs not him. It's no secret that people think I'm an easy mislynch target. They either bus Banez or me but I think the CP shot reveal obviously put that to a halt.

 

[Chris]

Because Magic is scum and shooting himself makes no sense? Everyone knew CP was riding high on POE. Magic even backed my reasoning for shooting CP not being on Jeff's wagon or OMB's lol.

People on CP were Lethal, me and Banez. Lethal died from lynch so obvs not him. It's no secret that people think I'm an easy mislynch target. They either bus Banez or me but I think the CP shot reveal obviously put that to a halt.

I don't think a sound scum strategy is shooting someone in POE that may have been the first wagon and a possible mislynch on their own right.

 

[Evans]

Bc the biggest hole in your theory for me is that you shot CP and I can't see why scum would think that was a good move over Poyser or Magic (though that wouldn't matter if he is scum like you say) but why CP over Poyser?

Poyser is an obvious person who is likely to be protected as he's been leading town this game. N0m's claim confirms this.

 

[Poyser]

Because Magic is scum and shooting himself makes no sense? Everyone knew CP was riding high on POE. Magic even backed my reasoning for shooting CP not being on Jeff's wagon or OMB's lol.

People on CP were Lethal, me and Banez. Lethal died from lynch so obvs not him. It's no secret that people think I'm an easy mislynch target. They either bus Banez or me but I think the CP shot reveal obviously put that to a halt.

If he’s high on PoE then that makes it a bad shot you know that right? Scum want to leave alive people that they can get lynched and shoot the ones they can’t. They’re not shooting cp to try and lynch the Vig so your theory is they shot cp solely to push exactly banez

 

[Evans]

I don't think a sound scum strategy is shooting someone in POE that may have been the first wagon and a possible mislynch on their own right.

No way was CP being lynched that early, especially since he hadn't claimed.

CP didn't like Magic's posts or his wagon on Jeff. CP isn't exactly a shit player either. Can you not see the reason why CP would have been shot? They've got one of the better players in POE, not on either scum wagon - it's not a crazy thought for them to shoot him than risk his claim derailing their wagon for a mislynch.

 

[Evans]

If he’s high on PoE then that makes it a bad shot you know that right? Scum want to leave alive people that they can get lynched and shoot the ones they can’t. They’re not shooting cp to try and lynch the Vig so your theory is they shot cp solely to push exactly banez

CP hadn't claimed. Any wagon on him could easily be disrupted by his claim. As above, they might have just shot CP to avoid having to deal with his claim (unknown to them at the time - obviously) and potentially getting caught trying to run a mislynch on him.

If anything shooting CP makes more sense than trying to force a mislynch on him before his claim lol

 

[Chris]

I just don't see it champ

 

[Showtime]

evans are you calling me a scared COWARD.

is this game not pretty much lock solved, poyser. do i actually have to do stuff.

 

[Evans]

evans are you calling me a scared COWARD.

is this game not pretty much lock solved, poyser. do i actually have to do stuff.

Just admit you're scum and be done with the game then

 

[Evans]

@Showtime

Where did OMB suggest he had a powerful role please?

 

[Poyser]

CP hadn't claimed. Any wagon on him could easily be disrupted by his claim. As above, they might have just shot CP to avoid having to deal with his claim (unknown to them at the time - obviously) and potentially getting caught trying to run a mislynch on him.

If anything shooting CP makes more sense than trying to force a mislynch on him before his claim lol

They wouldn’t even know he had a good role or not lol, scum don’t think like this otherwise you could invent a reason for shooting literally anybody “they didn’t want to deal with his claim”

 

[Showtime]

he said he had a role he never heard of before, not a powerful role.


i was wrong in saying that

it's almost as if i was skim reading

 

[Poyser]

evans are you calling me a scared COWARD.

is this game not pretty much lock solved, poyser. do i actually have to do stuff.

PoE is kinda open right now tbh. I still think Chris is town (haven’t read back at his posts) so for me it’s 2 of Rugrat/alco/brutus and lawls. Brutus and lawls have small points in their favour. Phenom isn’t exactly out of PoE either but as far as him and Banez’ claims go, they match up pretty well

 

[Evans]

They wouldn’t even know he had a good role or not lol, scum don’t think like this otherwise you could invent a reason for shooting literally anybody “they didn’t want to deal with his claim”

Exactly the reasoning. So you're saying there is no chance Magic who was already having poor interactions with CP doesn't take the chance and risk of CP claiming a town power role whilst trying to mislynch him over the Jeff & OMB wagons - which when CP then flipped town would put Magic centre point of suspicion, does not shoot CP instead?

 

[Poyser]

Exactly the reasoning. So you're saying there is no chance Magic who was already having poor interactions with CP doesn't take the chance and risk of CP claiming a town power role whilst trying to mislynch him over the Jeff & OMB wagons - which when CP then flipped town would put Magic centre point of suspicion, does not shoot CP instead?

Have you played with scum magic before?