MTG Mafia, Angels vs. Enemies - Game Thread

[Showtime]

also i liked my role variation @haza


and i disagree it's op @Jeffatron

it can just as easily be lost on day 1. it's not really the host's fault that poyser got himself to be an easy town read day 1 and i just protected him and banez protected me. it was a perfect situation/outcome of day 1. like i have no reason to risk protecting other people and im protected myself.

i do think there was a bit too many info roles/probably could have dropped the watcher role altogether, for example.

 

[RDK]

also i liked my role variation @haza


and i disagree it's op @Jeffatron

it can just as easily be lost on day 1. it's not really the host's fault that poyser got himself to be an easy town read day 1 and i just protected him and banez protected me. it was a perfect situation/outcome of day 1. like i have no reason to risk protecting other people and im protected myself.

i do think there was a bit too many info roles/probably could have dropped the watcher role altogether, for example.

you said it was a shitty role

"I guess. this is just like my other role in the other god damn game. why do i keep getting shitty bg roles where i cant self-protect. "

 

[Showtime]

you said it was a shitty role

"I guess. this is just like my other role in the other god damn game. why do i keep getting shitty bg roles where i cant self-protect. "

it was shitty in the sense i cant protect myself. i can like the variation and be annoyed i cant protect myself lol.


i was shot n1 in that game and shot n1 in this game(and it just so happened banez protected me), hence "shitty" role because it just means i kinda know ima die.

 

[RDK]

also i liked my role variation @haza


and i disagree it's op @Jeffatron

it can just as easily be lost on day 1. it's not really the host's fault that poyser got himself to be an easy town read day 1 and i just protected him and banez protected me. it was a perfect situation/outcome of day 1. like i have no reason to risk protecting other people and im protected myself.

i do think there was a bit too many info roles/probably could have dropped the watcher role altogether, for example.

I agree though, this game is was OP because of the outcome of D1, other games it would be next to useless. In the wrong hands it would also be useless.

 

[Poyser]

Also Magic still having shots obviously did me in, majorly. Didn't even stop 1 second to contemplate that could happen.

Yeah I’m surprised. Obviously wasn’t sure but I was kinda like magic is overdoing this “get your thoughts out poyser Cos you’re gonna die!!!” So bet he has shots left. Chuckled when I saw there was no kill lmao

 

[Showtime]

"yeah, i still think you gave town way too much power. 1 bus driver isnt enough to get around 2 protective roles (one thats not even x shot :s) + watcher + tracker . scum needed a roleblocker and strongman I think if town is going to be this loaded?"

watcher is what needed to be dropped, but tracker isn't that strong.

you do not need a strongman, scum busdriver is op.


literally just switch targets between the likely protected player and another player and suddenly protected player is dead and the bg looks suss because he didnt protect that player and needs to claim it was likely a busdriver.

 

[Poyser]

rugrat role + lethal unkowningly killing himself and a scum really flipped too. + the tweet kill andpoyser shot were also mistakes. alco may have actually pulled it off if not.

When Chris said “didn’t tweet say he softed his role” and I checked his post I legit laughed my ass off lmao

 

[Chris]

When Chris said “didn’t tweet say he softed his role” and I checked his post I legit laughed my ass off lmao

As soon as he died I was like "well he said he softed something himself so surely someone should be able to figure that out even if I can't" I hope I would have gotten it if I would have read through his posts before you

 

[Poyser]

I don't think getting Poyser to lynch Magic would've been all that impossible

 

[RDK]

I also like that way of doing Char Claiming/Flavor claiming. Just having it match the card and therefore taking out flavor spec. It's a nice inbetween to having no char claiming at all.

 

[Banez]

I'm glad my usage was useful in the end... HM worthy usage

 

[Poyser]

can you explain to me how me literally counterclaiming phen0m wasn't enough for you. :

I mean it was, I instantly voted PHEN0M with you when you did it lol. I unvoted because I wanted to discuss a bit further due to having a scum read on banez

 

[Poyser]

i think it was based on poyser's explanation as to why he or I weren't scum

i.e. there was no reason to not kill every night phase. situation never gets to final 3 if it isn't for that missing night kill and neither of us had any reason to not kill every night phase so it isn't something that would have been faked.

I mean that put it over the top but I was never ever lynching you after phenom lol. I could maybe have bought jeff as a bus (because you had a wagon on you too) at a stretch, but I’m never believing you bus jeff and phenom lol

 

[RDK]

I'm glad my usage was useful in the end... HM worthy usage

I was so confused when you claimed BG?

You had asked me questions about the Seraph role so I knew you didn't think you were actually BG

 

[Poyser]

MVP: Poyser
HM: Magic
HM: Banez

Poyser and Magic are pretty self explanatory. Banez just comes down to the right usage. He created the chain that kept the two names above him alive throughout and meant his flip was essential to scum winning the game. He never died and ALAS scum never really had a chance. Alco deserved an HM just for being persistent and never giving up. Who knows what might have happened if scum had of caught that Tweet soft too, that was the beginning of the end I feel.

Scum: https://www.quicktopic.com/53/H/u6TRZk2ShBrM
Dead: https://www.quicktopic.com/53/H/MKuCe7FwFaYQ

Told you you’re not shit, Banez!