As much as I hate to say it, Lady Hotrod does have a point in her initial arguments. Xtremebadass, from Mike's own admission, was most demoted because the majority of the forum found him as unpopular and didn't respect his position or authority as Admin. I'm still giving Constantine a chance, but it's looking like already that the mere fact that Constantine is so new and has done so little for the forum thus far that he doesn't have the respect or the reputation NEEDED for the members of this forum to respect his authority.
Like I said, I hope it still works out. Because God knows we need a stable staff more than another demotion. But this might just come down to the fact that Constantine hasn't earned his stripes, and his newness will be his worst enemy in terms of people being able to respect his decisions.