Btw I think the point that "CP usually has such a good grasp of my alignment" is pretty hollow if you consider how much he's drawn scum lately and only read me town because he knew I was, and that giving me town reads to try and pocket me was his usual shtick.
It's possible I'm just putting the scum motivation behind his posts even if they are not really there. I'd trust you know him better than I do. Likely wouldn't go for him first on Day 2 at any rate