Midnight Mass Mafia Game Thread — Game ended.

[Tweet]

Wow I go to sleep for 6 hours and the amount of pages has more than doubled. I don't exactly have time to catch up rn either.

 

[Nostradamus]

But why'd you feel the need to say "look I did it as town" when you can shitpost and make jokes as either alignment lol

Dude, I didn't say that in what you initially quoted, what lol

 

[Jobber Doink]

Do you lean more scum lazy or town lazy?

With everything he's done? Scum lazy and hope a new flavour or old one draws attention and we forget about zinger.

 

[Pendex]

With everything he's done? Scum lazy and hope a new flavour or old one draws attention and we forget about zinger.

Gotcha.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

pretty sure thats the main character

MC as a fake isn't impossible

 

[Chris]

Dude, I didn't say that in what you initially quoted, what lol

Okay fair enough lol you never commented on your alignment. I just read it that way myself. And with pendex not in the game, not saying the alignment kinda negates my whole point here

rescinding some of my sus lol

 

[Leon TrotSky]

No way they flipped it like Trailer Park did?

I have my own reasons to say it's unlikely

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Wow I go to sleep for 6 hours and the amount of pages has more than doubled. I don't exactly have time to catch up rn either.

Tweet finding another reason not to comment on the wagon of the moment

 

[Pendex]

I think a Main Character claim should be enough to at least not lynch them Day 1. It *can* be a fake claim, though it seems unlikely that the character themselves are scum. But we can address that tomorrow.

 

[Tweet]

Caught up, nothing worth responding to much.

@Tweet Evans' game, on MC.
@Poyser I say that Mafia are more likely to employ fallacy than Town because Mafia by definition have to obfuscate the truth which fallacies assist with. It's not, however, a boolean read where the existence of a fallacy makes one a scum lean. To go into this further is probably best saved for a Mafia discussion thread some other time.

---

Friday's vote doesn't make a great deal of sense to me. Jobber Doink's conclusion ultimately was not to vote for me (yet), so to use their reasoning to support a vote is a bit strange I feel. I liked how they opening admitted to bandwagoning though, felt very natural. Don't think my read of lean town has changed there.

I tend to agree that Tweet has been mostly content to bystand, even when things concern him.

I'm also pretty sure there is no more than one scum between myself (well obviously), Poyser, Sky, Friday and Johnny. The way the conversation developed felt like the classic town vs town arguments and while I hesitate to clear 5 other players it at least feels like it wasn't driven by scum. Will probably reconsider my vote in short order, we have about 15 hours remaining.

If I'm still leading when the NFL starts (so roughly 4 and a half hours from now) I'll claim, I think.

You were in that one? Frankly I barely remember that game. Also looking at the lineup you're probably going by a different nick on MC?

 

[Pendex]

You were in that one? Frankly I barely remember that game. Also looking at the lineup you're probably going by a different nick on MC?

I was Haruhiism. Killed Night 1.

 

[Comrade Khan]

it's not impossible but there's also so little actual play there it's giving me pause.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I think a Main Character claim should be enough to at least not lynch them Day 1. It *can* be a fake claim, though it seems unlikely that the character themselves are scum. But we can address that tomorrow.

I guess so, I'll unvote for now with the character and them hinting at having something powerful but no claim is frustrating

I'd rather have the full picture to work with as I don't trust them, and trusting character claims is not very smart with fakes out there

 

[Tweet]

Why have I suddenly shot above Jonny, I'd love to hear the reasons for this vote

I'm getting second thoughts about Jonny because he's been pretty unapologetic for his play around Pendex, and also it's not all that different from his play around Sky last game. You meanwhile I haven't vibed with at all and it seemed like an okay vote at the time.

 

[Smart Marx]

Unvote

He says his role is important and he'll "self-resolve" so that with this character claim, I guess we can give him the night.