Midnight Mass Mafia Game Thread — Game ended.

[Comrade Khan]

While I'm in the setup discussion talk does a Necromancer fit this flavour at all? Burning a revive which is usually limited shot on a tree stump for a player that wasn't all that engaged Day 1 seems like a rather poor use of the role to me.

its fucking weird ass usage, I have to assume whoever did that either wanted to blow their load right away out of excitement...or fear!

 

[Chris]

its fucking weird ass usage, I have to assume whoever did that either wanted to blow their load right away out of excitement...or fear!

Yeah I was thinking maybe they were worried about being killed so getting the town vote back was good? Most likely scenario is probs just wanting to resurrect the first dead towny probably tho which would point towards excitement I guess?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Yeah I was thinking maybe they were worried about being killed so getting the town vote back was good? Most likely scenario is probs just wanting to resurrect the first dead towny probably tho which would point towards excitement I guess?

this is also very possible and the "occams razor" currently

 

[Comrade Khan]

so some votes on lethal while we wait unless there's something else yall wanna push

 

[Smart Marx]

so some votes on lethal while we wait unless there's something else yall wanna push

Just out of curiosity what percentage would you currently give Lethal's chances of flipping scum?

And follow-up question, just as I asked Sky, what, if any, claims would change that percentage for you?

 

[Chris]

I feel like having a reviver as town could make a negative utility like hated more likely to be town too but that's a reach without knowing much else and OP says something about if you known Peter not to setup spec anyway lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

Just out of curiosity what percentage would you currently give Lethal's chances of flipping scum?

And follow-up question, just as I asked Sky, what, if any, claims would change that percentage for you?

percentage game is a tough one, I certainly dont have any mechanical info or anything like that. but I would say obviously above 50% since I'm pushing him. his read back was the epitomy of paper pushing and he never even gave a list. so it would take a very good claim or a strong switch in playstyle and him analyzing shit for me sway me currently.

now to be fair, he's the one that popped the hardest to me on my readback and i wasnt live playing as much as i usually am this weekend, so I have less other reads than I often have at this stage of the game, but I'm feeling pretty confident something aint right with our boy

 

[Smart Marx]

I feel like having a reviver as town could make a negative utility like hated more likely to be town too but that's a reach without knowing much else and OP says something about if you known Peter not to setup spec anyway lol

That's a good point. I'm not sure mathematically it would help too much unless non-town are 4 total. That would work.

 

[Comrade Khan]

like his play around sky was suuuuper hedgy and felt like it was over leaning on the "trying to be nice" while offering 0 of actual value reads wide, if that makes sense

 

[Comrade Khan]

and ya i already mentione dit, but the "im so pissed off at this post" answer by him...didnt read pissed off at all

 

[Chris]

like his play around sky was suuuuper hedgy and felt like it was over leaning on the "trying to be nice" while offering 0 of actual value reads wide, if that makes sense

I wanna say he did the same last game as well? Would have to check back though

 

[Comrade Khan]

I wanna say he did the same last game as well? Would have to check back though

and he was scum last game, indeed

 

[Smart Marx]

so it would take a very good claim or a strong switch in playstyle and him analyzing shit for me sway me currently.

So would it be fair to say you're more pushing to lynch than get a claim, barring he does have a strong claim and then you'd unvote?

My question towards playstyle, though, is I think Poyser mentioned this earlier, once it's pointed out, he'd be a fool not to change it, though?

 

[Comrade Khan]

So would it be fair to say you're more pushing to lynch than get a claim, barring he does have a strong claim and then you'd unvote?

My question towards playstyle, though, is I think Poyser mentioned this earlier, once it's pointed out, he'd be a fool not to change it, though?

a bit of a forceful conclusion but sure, I'd be lying if I said I didn't want to lynch him after last night

but dont get that twisted with the fact that Phenom's role and play sucks too and im not taking him off the table today. Im not ready to make that decision sans claim or further thoughts from the rest of class

 

[Comrade Khan]

So would it be fair to say you're more pushing to lynch than get a claim, barring he does have a strong claim and then you'd unvote?

My question towards playstyle, though, is I think Poyser mentioned this earlier, once it's pointed out, he'd be a fool not to change it, though?

to answer this two folds:

1- you would think so
2 - its lethal/easier said that done for some.

I don't want to sound like a prick, but Lethal's been trying to change up his scum game for years and up to last game, has not succeeded.