Midnight Mass Mafia Game Thread — Game ended.

[Poyser]

If you're as good as people say you are then checking makes sense. I'd rather have the active players cleared so you can trust their voice then work with them through the PoE. Clearing inactives that can be subbed for active players is a waste especially because I am suicidal as fuck with copping here.

This isn’t what happens with inactives tho, they’re usually just left around and get lynched later. More often than not it’s a mislynch

 

[Pendex]

This isn’t what happens with inactives tho, they’re usually just left around and get lynched later. More often than not it’s a mislynch

Only if the active players district each other and start attacking one another. Hence my choice. Get the active town core established and then let them work through the PoE. That was my reasoning especially because unlike a normal cop the price for catching scum with my role is death.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I'm a fan of clearing inactives too generally but I think Pendex's logic is fine for a player like poyser

Yea, I don't really see anything wrong with that. Pendex was pretty consistent. I'd probably Cop/Hide behind Poyser too just to clear any lingering doubts

I did that with Junk in WS Mafia, copped her because she was my main suspect and I couldn't drop it

 

[Poyser]

Pendex and Smark I'm both fine with being town, It's not totally impossible for those roles to co-exist and I'm not ruling out anything from the set-up I'm satisfied with how Pendex was hinting at the role too

Scum hiders are a thing, tho

also, pendex could easily have been the hider that thought they were town at the time lmao. Same is true of smark tho obviously lol, but his character being from the island makes that less likely. He’d either have to be town or had known he was scum from the start, which clearly isn’t true

 

[Marty McFourth]

Why is Poyser being voted btw? I've had him as Town this game so I'd need selling on that

 

[Kross Rhodes]

Scum hiders are a thing, tho

also, pendex could easily have been the hider that thought they were town at the time lmao. Same is true of smark tho obviously lol, but his character being from the island makes that less likely. He’d either have to be town or had known he was scum from the start, which clearly isn’t true

I'm glad someone knows this theme stuff so I don't have to fight for my town reads again.

 

[Pendex]

Scum hiders are a thing, tho

also, pendex could easily have been the hider that thought they were town at the time lmao. Same is true of smark tho obviously lol, but his character being from the island makes that less likely. He’d either have to be town or had known he was scum from the start, which clearly isn’t true

Oh my goodness. What the fuck.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Scum hiders are a thing, tho

also, pendex could easily have been the hider that thought they were town at the time lmao. Same is true of smark tho obviously lol, but his character being from the island makes that less likely. He’d either have to be town or had known he was scum from the start, which clearly isn’t true

True, I at least think Smark's character is in the game if I was to set-up spec with my character. His play has looked good for me as well

 

[Tweet]

What does that make tweet though if he was a zombie, did he come back as his original role or a new one? and with god army being dead what happens there?

I got revived as Gods Army aligned and converted back to town with the rest of them earlier

 

[Chris]

Arguing your different philosophies on how to use the hider role isn't really going to help us here lol I think it makes the most sense with how the scum team seemed to change the the people who are now scum didn't know before so judging motivations for him using the hider role one way rn seems weird to me anyway. The new scum team were probably playing as town, maybe there's some overlap the old team too, that's a possibility I could see over the confirmed townies

 

[Poyser]

I’d probably say I either wanna lynch pendex or one of the original scum team today tho. Of that team, I’d guess lethal probably makes the most sense. Maybe phenom if you want to role spec a little. CP has been slimy since the reveal too but idk. It’s just a shit shoot really. Could lynch anyone from that team except tweet and Jeff I’d say at this juncture

 

[Kross Rhodes]

I was definitely not previously scum as Jeff and company I think spilled the whole team.

 

[Pendex]

"I can't be wrong, he must be scum that just doesn't know it!"

I would love to have this sort of ego to be honest.

 

[Kross Rhodes]

I got revived as Gods Army aligned and converted back to town with the rest of them earlier

Man, you'd probably have won, too, because who really wants to lynch the revived townie.

 

[CraigPelton]

Arguing your different philosophies on how to use the hider role isn't really going to help us here lol I think it makes the most sense with how the scum team seemed to change the the people who are now scum didn't know before so judging motivations for him using the hider role one way rn seems weird to me anyway. The new scum team were probably playing as town, maybe there's some overlap the old team too, that's a possibility I could see over the confirmed townies

Giving Chris a town lean for counteracting poysers attempts to demoralize and distract me and my fellow townies