Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[T’Challa]

I asked him why he thinks Im scummy and his response was "your posts have been scummy as fuck"

Are you talking about Doddsy are you reading him as scum?

 

[Poyser]

Are you talking about Doddsy are you reading him as scum?

yes x2

 

[Comrade Khan]

I mean yea poyser b voting doddsy . I fkin hope he's scum reading him

 

[Comrade Khan]

That being said with banez flipping town , not really confident following him agai , either.

 

[T’Challa]

I think I rather vote Doddsy over Poyser if it comes down to those two.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Well I wouldn't disagree if it was a 1 or the other. Poyser has a shot he will need to prove.

Doddsy hadn't claimed tho so.im.missimg that part if the puzzle

 

[Comrade Khan]

Why do.u think lethal is scum btw ? Just the interactions w juice ?

 

[T’Challa]

Why do.u think lethal is scum btw ? Just the interactions w juice ?

She right, she asked a lot more questions in the last game and was pushing people harder. Her arguments with yourself and Ace I believe last game was based on the game and didn’t seem pointless. Her back and forth with Shields doesn’t look like scum hunting just more like a distraction to look like it.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Just FYI

Lethal: dude
Shielf maiden: girl

Your last post makes it super confusing who.ur talking about lol

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

Vote Count:

Rugrat ~ 3[Poyser, Grim, Jeff]
Lethal ~ 1[Juice]

And then Magic turns up dead. Yup, I think she's vain enough to pull the trigger.



I have Jeff as a town lean so no reason to doubt his result. Role mechanism suggests you're now confirmed town. Looking forward to working with you

Vote: Rugrat

Should be good enough for a claim here. Raisins, Poyser?

Vote Barry

Seems scummy

Anyway I'm fairly happy with Rugrat's response, don't need him to claim!

I think I'm gonna want to lynch jeff tbh but I'd like to get a claim at least from Doddsy as he's not done anything except push me and his post about the janitor pinged me. Essentially I said I wanted to lynch banez and if I'm wrong then you can lynch/shoot me and he replied saying I wanna get the janitor off but it doesn't make any sense because the counter wagon was Juice and I was never in any danger at all lol. I know he's probably gonna say it's a joke but he's just been trying to shade me any time he's been around and that was just furthering that

vote doddsy

Magic agreed that he'd been pinged by doddsy when I asked him about it as well fwiw

Vote: Juice

I'm going to leave my vote here. I hated her entry posts, hated her ignoring of my questions, hated her confidence on Banez being town [never actually said why, just picked apart my case as 'scummy'], and claimed the town doctor, which just smells to me as it wasn't in any of the flipped town players PMs, and with all of these protective roles around, she's the most suspect.

Anyway I'm going to bed

Vote Poyser

I think I’m leaning to read you as Town Jeff I like this post and yes I feel Lethal scum and with that
Vote Lethal

Vote Count:

Rugrat ~ 3[Grim, Jeff, Lethal]
Lethal ~ 2[Juice,T'Challa]
Grim ~ 1[Chimp]
Doddsy ~ 1[Poyser]
Juice ~ 1[Lethal]
Poyser ~ 1[Doddsy]

Around 9 hrs left

 

[T’Challa]

Just FYI

Lethal: dude
Shielf maiden: girl

Your last post makes it super confusing who.ur talking about lol

I was talking about Lethal.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'm going to go with what pinged me last night

vote Grim

i really hated that mq on rugrat as it felt like a fake scum read imo.

Magics reason for reading him town were prob the weakest of his town reads so I think its worth diving into. I'll see about looking at his d1 posts too later

 

[CakeWalker]

Just doing a quick skim read and I'm just looking at interactions - rather than actual content, and I am going to make my first revelation.

My previous scum reads were Chloe, Jeff and Lethal.

However - unless Jeff has come up with this approach on purpose, I believe that if himself and Lethal were on the same scum team some of these interactions wouldn't have taken place. Upon this obbo - Jeff and Lethal can't be on the same team.

Based on this theory - for the time being - not saying that I wont go back on it - I am going to move Jeff into a neutral standing.
It does however keep my sights very much locked on Lethal

 

[Ace]

Tbf tho if lethal has targeted jeff and got back a no result it probably means he actually is a hider? Obviously lethal wasn't blocked lol

I think you were posting this to me after I said Jeff is more likely to be scum than Kajuh - I just meant it as in if Kajuh is scum then Jeff basically can't be town because he would have lied about usage on Kajuh. Whereas Jeff can be scum and Kajuh still town.

Also Jeff can be a hider/commuter who is scum tbf. I'm not denying at this point that he clearly has either the role he is claiming, or one close enough.

Ie Lethal's result on him is definitely legit.

 

[Poyser]

I think I've only ever seen a scum hider once but yeah it's possible