Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Showtime]

i mean at least odo is solidly town

 

[CraigPelton]

i mean at least odo is solidly town

Wish he would stick around and actually be useful instead of stomping off lmao

 

[Poyser]

why would i do any of that as scum? that doesnt remotely fit my scum play lol. I'm not oversimplifying it at all, it's just a really weak reason to try to sus me. even if you think it's out of character for my town self, there has to be some reason that it's scummy too, which is my whole point. it was just something you thought was bad so you pushed it.

you waited for jeff to continue his argument against odo until he made himself look worse until you joined so it doesn't look as bad as when you join lol.

Have you even read my posts about jeff or are you still just talking shite about my earlier vote?

you’d do it as scum because it’s easy. You literally spent last game complaining about me and Jeff posting too much. Did you vote any of us for it then? Even once? No, of course not because it’s fucking stupid. Yet you did here, so there must be something causing the change in tactic so it’s completely fair to ponder that it might be because you’re scum. Miss me with this shit

 

[Smart Marx]

So Odo broke one of his own rules about not asking to rep out publicly?

Guys, can we all take a deep breathe and not ruin Blaine's first game, please? I'd appreciate it.

 

[Showtime]

Have you even read my posts about jeff or are you still just talking shite about my earlier vote?

you’d do it as scum because it’s easy. You literally spent last game complaining about me and Jeff posting too much. Did you vote any of us for it then? Even once? No, of course not because it’s fucking stupid. Yet you did here, so there must be something causing the change in tactic so it’s completely fair to ponder that it might be because you’re scum. Miss me with this shit

last game i ended up not reading the thread and missing out on crucial details in end game. kinda fucked over town, yes? why would i want to repeat that lol.

 

[Showtime]

also that is a really weak comparison as i had you as town last game and there was no real wagon on either of you the entire time. there was literally a wagon on jeff and i voted him saying i dont really care.

 

[Poyser]

last game i ended up not reading the thread and missing out on crucial details in end game. kinda fucked over town, yes? why would i want to repeat that lol.

Well that’s a fairer point but you didn’t say that at the time you just said you’re voting him because you don’t care if he dies

 

[Poyser]

also that is a really weak comparison as i had you as town last game and there was no real wagon on either of you the entire time. there was literally a wagon on jeff and i voted him saying i dont really care.

What are you talking about, there was absolutely a wagon on jeff and nobody read him town til around the time you died

 

[Showtime]

vote jeff

i will follow odo and cp


and cause he will overpost to a point i wont be able to read the thread and i dont want that again.

vote magic

yeah i dont buy this

i finished last game not being able to read the thread and i''ve continuously complained about it. then i asked him and he said he didn't. then he has a wagon. so why not?

i mean im not just following them, it's clearly cause of my request being denied i dont care if he gets wagoned lol.

for what it's worth i view the poyser vote and reasoning as scummy itself because it looks like he just went for something that he knew he could make me look bad with.

there's no discernment from him whether or not what i'm doing is town vs. scum, more than it comes across as it's easy for me to look bad via what i said.

Because you're not actually gonna vote someone out of the game for this shite lmao come on

i mean i have no read on him. if i think he's town i won't.

otherwise i don't care. odo and cp read him scum. should i OPPOSE for the sake of opposing?

read our exchange.

you referred to what i was doing incorrectly multiple times to make it look worse than it was because the vote itself was basically a nothing vote.

you implied i would vote him out over this, when i never said that i was just voting. i even clarified it's cause i have no read on him and i wouldnt vote him out if i thought he was town.

you were grasping early and it just doesnt look like a read youd make as town because it lacks any nuance or depth. it's literally "this vote is bad so youre scummy"

 

[CraigPelton]

Well a lot of people still haven't posted so I'm gonna come back to this later

unvote

 

[Showtime]

im with my friend cp. ive said my piece, people can see if they want to side with me or not as now im flooding the thread and there's already a ton of posts. ill give others a chance to catch up.

 

[Banez]

Magic is probably town.

 

[Poyser]

read our exchange.

you referred to what i was doing incorrectly multiple times to make it look worse than it was because the vote itself was basically a nothing vote.

you implied i would vote him out over this, when i never said that i was just voting. i even clarified it's cause i have no read on him and i wouldnt vote him out if i thought he was town.

you were grasping early and it just doesnt look like a read youd make as town because it lacks any nuance or depth. it's literally "this vote is bad so youre scummy"

Yes you clarified you wouldn’t vote him out if you thought he was town and I moved off from you because I found something better. I didn’t like your vote but it was essentially a snap reaction and there’s really not gonna be a lot of nuance in my vote that early in the game. There certainly wasn’t in yours!

but yet it’s funny because I feel like what you’re accusing me of doing is pretty much what you’re doing now. You’re framing my change to jeff as something different than what it actually was just to make me look bad. It’s why I asked if you even read my posts around jeff because from going from your own posts, you haven’t.

 

[CakeWalker]

I'm confused - why is Odo asking to be repped out?

 

[Poyser]

Because he’s a smurf