what is redundant about the read? its perfectly acceptable and perfectly logical. I was also giving my thoughts on the miller spec u guys spent what, 1 page or two discussing and coming to no conclusion either. Giving my opinion on said miller is not redundant, or scummy. wrong.
Questioning why someone is voting someone is perfectly acceptable, and well within the realms of my town game. There's nothing scummy about it at all, and I do it as all alignments.
I was pretty easily scum read by a few last game, that much is true, but I got out of it through play and role, also true. I'm not really seeing how I'm really playing any way similar, however.
Anything else?