Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Odo]

miller claim is exactly how any miller should play, or anyone with a miller fake would play it. Still, going to lean town at face value as 1) Blaine probably doesnt give that as a given fake given his experience level Ive had with him thus far as a player and 2) It's way too risky of a fake to come up on your own on d1, since, you know, they could simply be a real miller to cc.

completely redundant

@Showtime why cp

I’m not inclined to believe you’re actually interested in the answer beyond stoking up dissent. I feel town you would frame this question further, like asking which post he didn’t like or something. This strikes me as a tick box exercise.

you too @Laughable Chimp

As above.

you were read pretty easily day 1 last game but used your role to your advantage - you got away with it but it doesn’t change that you were sniffed out quickly

 

[CraigPelton]

I AM ASKING FOR PROTECTION TONIGHT, this post may generate some controversy later and make me appear super selfish but as I speak to you across time know that within my madness there is contained a method

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Jeff what do you think of Banez

NULL? He has 7 posts, no votes, and called me smart fsr. Not sure how I'm supposed to get a read there or the relevance of this question. What's YOUR read on Banez?

 

[CraigPelton]

completely redundant



I’m not inclined to believe you’re actually interested in the answer beyond stoking up dissent. I feel town you would frame this question further, like asking which post he didn’t like or something. This strikes me as a tick box exercise.



As above.

you were read pretty easily day 1 last game but used your role to your advantage - you got away with it but it doesn’t change that you were sniffed out quickly

yep we are on the same page. And who was the first to be pinged by jeff and vote him last game, one of the first votes in the game iirc?

It's ya boy

 

[Poyser]

Not sure why the post count is relevant, barry has 9 posts and you’re voting him

I haven’t liked banez entrance hence why I voted him.

 

[Odo]

You then prioritised magic saying that he cba to read your posts as a way of invalidating his vote. This would be fine if he actually tried to justify the vote with that, but he openly said he has no read on you, just doesn’t care if you live or die

 

[Showtime]

@CraigPelton @Odo

hello

would you guys consider barry vindictive?

 

[Poyser]

Barry is vindictive

not tagging me is an affront

 

[Odo]

@CraigPelton @Odo

hello

would you guys consider barry vindictive?

yes

 

[CraigPelton]

@CraigPelton @Odo

hello

would you guys consider barry vindictive?

not to the point he would commit to something rash but enough to rattle sticks

 

[Odo]

If he drew a day kill, flay is probs dead

that level of vindictive

 

[Canadian Dragon]

completely redundant



I’m not inclined to believe you’re actually interested in the answer beyond stoking up dissent. I feel town you would frame this question further, like asking which post he didn’t like or something. This strikes me as a tick box exercise.



As above.

you were read pretty easily day 1 last game but used your role to your advantage - you got away with it but it doesn’t change that you were sniffed out quickly

what is redundant about the read? its perfectly acceptable and perfectly logical. I was also giving my thoughts on the miller spec u guys spent what, 1 page or two discussing and coming to no conclusion either. Giving my opinion on said miller is not redundant, or scummy. wrong.


Questioning why someone is voting someone is perfectly acceptable, and well within the realms of my town game. There's nothing scummy about it at all, and I do it as all alignments.

I was pretty easily scum read by a few last game, that much is true, but I got out of it through play and role, also true. I'm not really seeing how I'm really playing any way similar, however.


Anything else?

 

[Odo]

You didn’t get out of it through play lol, I was watching the game

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Not sure why the post count is relevant, barry has 9 posts and you’re voting him

I haven’t liked banez entrance hence why I voted him.

is this an actual point? have you seen the difference in quality in posts and content?

 

[Odo]

On day 1 that is