Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Ace]

Poyser isnt a scum read of mine -

Here you at least signal you don't think Poyser is scum but even so, I feel like there were better targets given the state of play.

That said ignoring the thread and going with your own reads would suit your play so far so perhaps its not that strange at all, just bad.

 

[CakeWalker]

I mean I scum read Chloe - they've been killed - im guessing by Showtime.

My other two scum reads are Jeff and Lethal.

I believed Poyser claiming to be the Jacks Of All Trades - and so I protected them. And I will continue to protect them.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I don't necessarily think Poyser is or should be a scum read at the moment. POE down the line maybe, but not a scum lean.

 

[Lethal]

why?

none of that really looked genuine to me.

she never reacted to me being the one to start her wagon, she didnt react to anything i said in regards to lethal being town and continued to argue with jeff, and then her level of sureness of banez being town just rubbed me the wrong way.

@Poyser that janitor post didnt ping me, but him going into the town benefits of banez role did.

And then Magic turns up dead. Yup, I think she's vain enough to pull the trigger.

@Lethal Banks Since you had me as poe, what are your thoughts on this?

I have Jeff as a town lean so no reason to doubt his result. Role mechanism suggests you're now confirmed town. Looking forward to working with you

Vote: Rugrat

Should be good enough for a claim here. Raisins, Poyser?

 

[Rugrat]

Vote: Rugrat

Should be good enough for a claim here. Raisins, Poyser?

Why are you voting me when someone hasn’t good even given any reasons?

it’s fine later game, but what do you get by blindly following Poyser at this point?

I know for a fact he has no legit info - and if he is town with some bogus info he believes is tru he’s playing it very badly even then.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

And then Magic turns up dead. Yup, I think she's vain enough to pull the trigger.



I have Jeff as a town lean so no reason to doubt his result. Role mechanism suggests you're now confirmed town. Looking forward to working with you

Vote: Rugrat

Should be good enough for a claim here. Raisins, Poyser?

 

[Rugrat]

If people think I’m claiming on a “case” with literally no reasons or info then dream the fuck on

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I think Poyser is town for this, I wouldn't be surprised if the stuff with Juice was bussing

Why are you voting me when someone hasn’t good even given any reasons?

it’s fine later game, but what do you get by blindly following Poyser at this point?

I know for a fact he has no legit info - and if he is town with some bogus info he believes is tru he’s playing it very badly even then.

Can you elaborate what you mean by busing?

Do you think poyser is town or not?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Rugrat personally feels like a logical next step. There's not much that pings me about everyone else's posts at the moment while his feel as if they're wildly overstating the obvious or just blending in and trying to look useful.

 

[Rugrat]

Rugrat personally feels like a logical next step. There's not much that pings me about everyone else's posts at the moment while his feel as if they're wildly overstating the obvious or just blending in and trying to look useful.

Which posts then kid? Give them

you’ve clearly just jumped on Poyser’s bandwagon.

 

[Rugrat]

Can you elaborate what you mean by busing?

Do you think poyser is town or not?

I wouldn’t be surprised if Flay and Juice were budding because of Flay wanting to give Kajuh a town read.

I stated earlier on in the thread that I think Poyser is town. Just that he doesn’t have info and his way of revealing info in this case is very poor if he is town w/info, but he has no info

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Its also absolutely fair to say poyser was under suspicion barry. He got voted to claim yesterday, magic had him as sk b4 dying. So let's call a spade a spade. I'm following his case and voting with him on the assumption he has info. But he's certainly not above suspicion

 

[Rugrat]

@Grimus Augustus

I’m waiting patiently for you

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I wouldn’t be surprised if Flay and Juice were budding because of Flay wanting to give Kajuh a town read.

I stated earlier on in the thread that I think Poyser is town. Just that he doesn’t have info and his way of revealing info in this case is very poor if he is town w/info, but he has no info

I don't dislike your first point. Its certainly possible n I still think juice has done jack shit.

Interesting second point. I look forward to hearing more

 

[Rugrat]

The smart play for a town Poyser with info would be:

push me for read list as I do loads, continue pushing as he is a leading voice in the thread to see who bites and who my hypothetical teammates are, if the wagon doesn’t catch on or there’s a competing wagon (which in his eyes would likely be a town player) then he’d reveal the info.

now he’s alluded to info at start of day, even if you were to work on the basis hes town and I’m scum you get nothing from it. He’s either scum and faking info, town with tampered info or most likely town and just suggesting info without being overt about it to get a wagon or read on me