LC11: Andy v. BDC v. Derrick v. Lubaninho

[Andy]

Andy's Entry

BDC's Entry

Derrick's Entry

Lubaninho's Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
PLEASE RANK YOUR VOTES FROM 1 TO 4 WITH ONE BEING YOUR FAVORITE AND FOUR BEING YOUR LEAST FAVORITE ENTRY. The piece with the lowest average will be the winner, and in the case of the tie, total #1 votes will be the deciding factor. If you are involved in the match, you may vote, but any votes for yourself will not be counted.
The battle will close on Monday July 2, 2012 at 10 P.M. (Central Time)
Good luck!​

 

[The_King]

Andy: Really like this piece. Nice use of color. Everything flows well, and the effects work. Font choice is definitely good, but it's missing a 'wow' factor for me.
BDC: Another solid piece from you. The main render, lyrics, and main text all work for me, but the extra renders on low opacity take it down a few notches for me. I like skyline background.
Derrick: Left my comments in your thread. Pulled off the paint-esque background well and perfectly incorporated the logo. Render could flow better though, and I think you need a light source somewhere to draw our attention to the render more.
Lubaninho: Left my comments in your thread as well. Solid piece, but it's size is its downfall. It just leaves too much blank space unfortunately. If it was smaller, it would've looked great.

1. Derrick
2. Andy
3. BDC
4. Lubaninho

Between Derrick and Andy for me, but I have to give it Derrick.

 

[Doink]

1. BDC
2. Derrick
3. Lubaninho
4. Andy

Great piece by BDC, he gets my vote

 

[Defiant]

1. Derrick
2. Andy
3. Lubaninho
4. BDC

 

[Rated R Superstar]

That was not the best choice of a picture on the right side there BDC.

Derrick is my choice for this one. His just seems the most clear cut. It's not extremely basic, but at the same time, it has the simple qualities which I like.

 

[The_King]

That was not the best choice of a picture on the right side there BDC.

Derrick is my choice for this one. His just seems the most clear cut. It's not extremely basic, but at the same time, it has the simple qualities which I like.

Thanks for voting, but any chance you can rank the four entries?

 

[Heisenberg]

1. Derrick
2. Andy
3. Lubaninho
4. BDC

 

[Ryan]

1. Derrick
2. Andy
3. Lubaninho
4. BDC

Derrick entry just flows the best and is the most well blended so I had to go with it.

 

[The_King]

Final Rankings:
1. Derrick (1.167)
2. Andy (2.333)
3. BDC (3.000)
4. Lubaninho (3.000)
Congrats to Derrick on the win!