Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Bobby Barrows]

Yeah Smark is a lynch I'd be fine with, it seems almost nobody is reading him town which isn't a great sign with him.

Also Jeffs reaction earlier screams non-town to me

I am. Unless you count me as "nobody".

 

[Ace]

I'm with Magic - y'all need to post less.

So with the duel, I'm a bit confused why when everyone was sussing Brutus earlier, everyone's suddenly basically saying Chimp and Brutus are basically both confirmed town...

I do think there's a solid chance they're both town but I see little reason for the confidence many seem to have. Did I miss something where Brutus all but cleared himself somehow?

I think Chimp is almost certainly town based on play - I struggle to see why scum team should a) force a d1 duel on an unclaimed Brutus [no claim, not a threatening player, at risk of being lynched anyway] and b) Trust Chimp to make it work.

Brutus I'm kind of indifferent on and don't think I would have ended up lynching but clearly there is a decent shot there. Not that I think Chimp should have triggered the duel, but given that he has, I see little reason not to just go along with it.

Vote Chimp to win duel

Also for those wondering why I'm on Tweet's scum list, tbf there was something a while back where he sussed me of something or at least questioned it, honestly I can't remember what it was because I was doing a readthrough at the time and it was meh enough that I just carried on. But there is at least some degree of justification for him scumreading me, albeit I do feel like he's purposefully putting a lot of weak scumreads into his list to make himself look good for having them.

 

[Tweet]

I am. Unless you count me as "nobody".

Why is Smark town then?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Why is Smark town then?

His play around your wagon for the most part, his over-cautiousness is something of a big town tell of mine and I don't believe he would do so if you were both scum together.

So there you go. Feel free to disagree with it, but it's not inconsistent with a previous post of mine on Smark.

 

[TKOK]

What's the vote count?

 

[Tweet]

vote Smark

To put it somewhere where it actually has a chance of accomplishing anything

 

[Odo]

Vote Count 6

Tweet 6 - Jeff, Lethal, Phenom, Poyser, Chimp, Barry
Haza 2 - Magic, Big Man
Brutus 2 - Doddsy, Alco
Smark 3 - CP, Tchalla, Tweet

Duel votes to win

Brutus 3 - Brutus, CP, Tchalla
Chimp 10 - Chimp, Poyser, Barry, Jeff, Phenom, Big Man, Doddsy, Tweet, Ace

You have just under 4 hours remaining. 11 to lynch.

 

[Poyser]

I thought he drew mass attention on himself for absolutely no reason at the time. We didn’t know who the traitor was but it wasn’t like he was going to get voted of by the scum team I was in.

 

[Tweet]

Welp looks like it's me or nothing

 

[Poyser]

Looks like it’s tweet or nothing folks you know what to do

not really sure what to make of T’Challa being pretty much willing to vote anybody except tweet lmao. I feel like that’s gonna look bad no matter what tweet flips?

 

[Poyser]

Vote Count 6

Tweet 6 - Jeff, Lethal, Phenom, Poyser, Chimp, Barry
Haza 2 - Magic, Big Man
Brutus 2 - Doddsy, Alco
Smark 3 - CP, Tchalla, Tweet

Duel votes to win

Brutus 3 - Brutus, CP, Tchalla
Chimp 10 - Chimp, Poyser, Barry, Jeff, Phenom, Big Man, Doddsy, Tweet, Ace

You have just under 4 hours remaining. 11 to lynch.

I believe haza voted for chimp to win

because I was just about to @Raidokken and ask what changed from thinking chimp orchestrated it?

 

[Poyser]

I kinda agree that Jeff doesn’t exactly scream obvtown on play which is concerning lol

 

[Tweet]

Poyser do you have any town reads or is everybody just looking varying shades of bad to you?

 

[Poyser]

Poyser do you have any town reads or is everybody just looking varying shades of bad to you?

Not as many as I would like which is worrying!

I think chimp and big man are town. I think it’s looking more likely that haza is town. CP seems town to me so far. Lethal is definitely town. Barry probably town. I like phenom for town.

to a lesser extent I think ace and alco both look fine

ftr this was cheap shade, I haven’t done a reads list but I’ve commented on people being town plenty. Again it’s just a case of you trying to make me look bad rather than actually figure me out.

fwiw I did also have magic as town but you see why it’s a problem when he’s just refusing to consider you for pretty weak reasons and ignored the point that was most damning against you to push haza who had already claimed. Now, I don’t mind him pushing haza for a lynch with no claim at all, it’s the fact he didn’t even realise haza claimed which kinda shows he hasn’t been reading haza’s post which is what makes it a shady push and possible diversion to me.

fwiw I also think Jeff is probably town due to the role as well, but it’s definitely worrying that the guy that’s usually a really easy read doesn’t look obv town to me on the merit of his play

 

[Poyser]

Oh Doddsy town too