Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

Alco going out of his way to read things differently to the class is usually a good sign iirc but I don’t really have a nailed meta for him or anything I usually just kinda try and vibe him out

I usually just look to see if he’s really engaged and it usually works out, but he did just have a good scum game I think?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Can you tell me in your own words why Brutus is scum?

Sure, see this exchange.

Haza who’s your mason partner, lad

Yes, cease and desist

We're a ways out of the fluff phase and this just doesn't help things currently.

Why is everyone so willing to vote Jeff so he could get his ability?

Now you said he was questioning the wagon and distrustful of the wagon itself, no?

Don’t you find it odd nobody is objecting though?

Actually probably not object but try and get someone to claim instead. What’re your thoughts on the people on Jeff’s wagon atm? I feel like scum could’ve been like “Okay , Jeff’s got something up his sleeve, vote for him and nobody will bat an eye”

Very WIFOM to say what scum would do, and at the same time he still questions the wagon.

Fair enough point. Vote Jeff

And then he just backsteps and votes on the wagon anyways. I would imagine Brutus would have had enough conviction to stay true and keep off the wagon even if it was explained to him.

I definitely wouldn’t argue that as scum. I’d do what scum did to the Jeff wagon and just hop on it, no questions asked.

More WIFOM.

So Jeff could get his ability, yes, and then I made a point, asking why everybody was jumping on it. It smelled, as it was easy for scum to blend in.

He's still quoting scum motivation after he already questioned the wagon and why it was happening. It just feels like he's walking back his positions even though he was so adamant about questioning the people *on* the wagon.


This exchange just doesn't sit right with me at all.

 

[Smart Marx]

Since you just read back, did smark ever actually vote tweet?

I didn’t, no.

 

[Smart Marx]

Btw people made the point that it's a smokescreen that I'm sussing Haza based on meta reasons I'm not willing to disclose. Magic is sussing Haza for literally the same reason with quite literally the same verbiage, did anybody question him?

I just did, yeah. It’s something I’m quite interested in.

 

[Doddsy]

Sorry yeah Meetra Surik is my character

Nah. I have their characters name in my PM though and flavor wise it seems legit

Declaration: Meetra Surik is the playable character of KOTOR 2 by the way

Query: Which meatbag is your mason? Not player, character. Is it Kreia aka Darth Traya?

Conclusion: Chimp is probably town. Magic is probably town. I think Haza is town as well.

Declaration: I kind of don't like the vibe I'm getting from GOATnom. If I had skin it'd be crawling but I don't really know why

Query: Did that meatbag Brutus claim yet?

 

[Smart Marx]

To play devils advocate, what's the point of him stalling for a claim if he's got a tracker claim ready to go?

That’s what gets me. It feels like town knowing the claim would get them boned. As scum I’d more expect Doddsy’s claim is gonna be scummy and just claim it.

 

[NotBrutus]

These were all the posts you made in b

Spoiler

Vote: Brutus

I like this direction tbh and Brutus screams feeling off and just trying to look busy.

He asked for votes mate.

I think Magic slipped.

Nah I don't really think his thoughts line up perfectly. He could clarify things a little further or y'know, dumb shit down so even I, an idiot, can understand.

Okay, so he says the wagon is shit, but that Jeff's play is shit. Right? Okay, so does he think it's shit town play or shit play in general that doesn't make him look good? Finally, he throws in indy-spec on the role. So does Magic think Jeff is town, scum, or Indy? And if so, why is the wagon shit if he doesn't think Jeff is town anymore?

I need answers bro.

Okay, but what does he read Jeff rn? He's throwing in indy-spec atm so it's deliberately confusing and I don't think he's clarifying his read on Jeff.

I don't want *you* Poyser defending and answering for him. I want his answer on this particular question:

How do you read Jeff, and what has caused it to change if it has?

I guess what I'm saying is for Magic to re-declare his own position on Jeff. Does he believe Jeff is Indy merely on the role or does it have to do with play as well? And secondly, would he believe that an Indy Jeff would show his hand so readily when it possibly hurts town and thus hurts him in the long run?

What is this guy on about. Thoughts please, Chloe.

But Flay is null on your list.

I'm fairly sure he meant that too, I'm just giving him shit.

The man mistook me for Flay. You hate to see it.

More votes on Brutus please.

Not one mention of me, until they re-voted. Didn’t mention me before your first vote either.

Completely different from the last game we played together where you couldn’t stop mentioning me, and asking people’s thoughts on me. You were the first vote yeah, but Poyser and Big Man were the first ones to sus me, very opportunistic.

 

[Smart Marx]

Yeah I skimmed it pretty much



Possible he was waiting to gain a suitable character to match it to his role. Last Odo game I was scum in he provided us with a set of fake characters, but nothing to claim with them - we had to do the leg work. It could have been Nintendo? We worked together to make my fake match up to Yoshi. KOTOR is a very niche brand of the lore of Star Wars, so waiting for someone with great knowledge to suit would be ideal for those who aren't aware.

Yeah, This tracks with my experience.

 

[Smart Marx]

Not gonna lie, even though I suss Tweet I'm uncomfortable at how easily this lynch is just cruising along without much contest.
Maybe it's just paranoia but I don't like it when there is such an uncontested lynch on d1.

This.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

These were all the posts you made in b
Not one mention of me, until they re-voted. Didn’t mention me before your first vote either.

Completely different from the last game we played together where you couldn’t stop mentioning me, and asking people’s thoughts on me. You were the first vote yeah, but Poyser and Big Man were the first ones to sus me, very opportunistic.

Cool story bro.

 

[NotBrutus]

 

[Smart Marx]

Why? What would you expect a hypothetical scum team to be doing here if tweet is scum?

Tracker isn’t a death sentence. There could be people playing devil’s advocate as you said to say something like that’s give him a chance to catch scum and then we lynch him if he doesn’t or something along those lines.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

 

[NotBrutus]

Sure, see this exchange.




We're a ways out of the fluff phase and this just doesn't help things currently.



Now you said he was questioning the wagon and distrustful of the wagon itself, no?




Very WIFOM to say what scum would do, and at the same time he still questions the wagon.



And then he just backsteps and votes on the wagon anyways. I would imagine Brutus would have had enough conviction to stay true and keep off the wagon even if it was explained to him.



More WIFOM.



He's still quoting scum motivation after he already questioned the wagon and why it was happening. It just feels like he's walking back his positions even though he was so adamant about questioning the people *on* the wagon.


This exchange just doesn't sit right with me at all.

Cool story bro.

 

[NotBrutus]

@Ace what’re your thoughts on Alco, after your initial exchange.

Vise versa.