Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

I don't particularly like how you backtrack almost immediately here. First phrase is you thinking Doddsy could be scum, first part of the second phrase confirms it, but then with the last part you just immediately build in the fail safe.

I think you missed the word “could” in the beginning of that sentence. I wasn’t gonna immediately scum read someone for having a pr. I’m just always fishy of them.

 

[Tweet]

I'm not sure if its scum-flailing or legit survival desperation-flailing but Tweet is definitely flailing.

Flailing.

Like most of the posts he's just quoted are kinda minor except chimp's which i think was tongue-in-cheek.

Sure an actual wagon jumped on afterwards but I would hardly look poorly at Barry for it.

It's not just that post in isolation, look back at this phase and you'll find he's been voting with the concensus opinion all day long.

 

[Smart Marx]

im on board

vote barry


out of everyone that has posted in the first 80 posts, he's the scummiest link.

What was it that popped out to you in those 80?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

It's not just that post in isolation, look back at this phase and you'll find he's been voting with the concensus opinion all day long.

I voted Jeff first as a joke lmfao. I've also willingly given town reads of my own accord. I'm sorry that I agree with most of town.

 

[Smart Marx]

smark is also town

haza looks suss for being a try hard and his lame try hard questions. page 7 done.

Is that something you wouldn’t expect Haza to do?

 

[NotBrutus]

Barry, has there ever been a game where you town read me?

More votes on Brutus please.

Plus you made this post as soon as CP and Poyser re-voted. Didn’t mention me in the posts following your initial one either.

 

[Tweet]

I realize I've shot us all in the foot here because I legitimately can't tell who's actually scummy for wanting to lynch me as I realize people have a point when it comes to my logical inconsistencies. Magic and Doddsy are kinda my only town reads atm because Magics thoughts align with mine for the most part, and he and Doddsy seem to actually realize that I might be wacky but not necessarily scummy.

 

[Tweet]

I voted Jeff first as a joke lmfao. I've also willingly given town reads of my own accord. I'm sorry that I agree with most of town.

Can you tell me in your own words why Brutus is scum?

 

[Smart Marx]

How is he playing offence? I don’t even think he’s voting anybody at the time you said this lol

He seemed to be making a case on you, a case on me and a case on Haza. I don’t particularly agree with them and he refused to help me on his read on Haza, though. Also, wasn’t he voting for me or Haza?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Barry, has there ever been a game where you town read me?




Plus you made this post as soon as CP and Poyser re-voted. Didn’t mention me in the posts following your initial one either.

I believe I have in the past, but in fairness my friend, you come off naturally scummy.

Also, those posts again came around the same time as my comment. So a bit misleading.

 

[Smart Marx]

vote haza
I’ll help here tho for now as I agree his logic with the jeff thing didn’t really track

What wasn’t clicking for you?

 

[Tweet]

Btw people made the point that it's a smokescreen that I'm sussing Haza based on meta reasons I'm not willing to disclose. Magic is sussing Haza for literally the same reason with quite literally the same verbiage, did anybody question him?

 

[Smart Marx]

Readback over

1. Haza
2. Alco
3. T'Challa
4. Poyser
5. Ace
6. Tweet
7. Big Man
8. Barry
9. Smark
10. Brutus
11. Blaine
12. CP
13. Magic
14. Kajuh
15. Jeff
16. Doddsy
17. Lethal
18. TKOK
19. Phenom
20. Chimp
21. Flay

where I'm at.
Haza had similar thoughts to mine, I don't see what Big Man's seeing tbh.
Poyser's push on Tweet feels genuine. CP was jokey at first but the vote on Jeff and subsequent posts made me think his intentions are GOOD.
Smark's backtrack and apparent lack of commitment make me feel uneasy. Jeff's posts pre-vote-campaign sit badly with me and while the role might be legit, I'm not sure if it's alignment indicative per se . I can also see a world in which Smark and Jeff are aligned.
Very unsure about the Tweety baby. I think I liked him better as the game progressed, but can't shake the feeling that Poy was bang on with his initial assessment . The claim does nothing either.

Me being scum doesn’t make much sense imo with my play on Jeff if he’s town, but I can see the logic if we’re both scum so I don’t entirely hate this read. I’ll give Alco a slight town read for being proactive and giving reads.

 

[Smart Marx]

Although, he’s also got Tweet yellow and that would be a weird scum trio.

 

[Smart Marx]

Also both Jeff and Tweet being yellow is annoying, cause at the same time I can't see them being aligned

At least he addressed that here.