Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Big Man]

So Jeff could get his ability, yes, and then I made a point, asking why everybody was jumping on it. It smelled, as it was easy for scum to blend in.

but it doesn’t help scum at all, unless Jeff is also scum and has that role.

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Odo can we has vote count?

 

[Poyser]

jeff's whole ploy is shit, there's a value in being subtle and discrete rather than open wolfing.


why

oh.

are we gonna lynch him? because this just screams indy role and i've had this same role in the past.

Why did you think the wagon was shit if you also thought his play was shit lol?

 

[Comrade Khan]

not to mention he called me one of his 3 towns upon entry and i had very much already gave my role up then no?

 

[Showtime]

Why did you think the wagon was shit if you also thought his play was shit lol?

because shit play doesn't mean scum play. it's shit because i dont think it generates reactions that would be easily discernible for people's alignment, also something scum could easily hide behind.

 

[Poyser]

because shit play doesn't mean scum play. it's shit because i dont think it generates reactions that would be easily discernible for people's alignment, also something scum could easily hide behind.

Ok, can you read some of my back and forth with tweet and tell me what you think? Dont need to go through all of it as we retread a lot of the same ground but at least the early stuff

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I think Magic slipped.

 

[Comrade Khan]

doddsy prob town too cause he would hide behind the pr like a coward.

that's 3 people out of 21.

i am only going to read from where i left off, i dont give a shit about phase the game is on. i'll solve it all via day 1 and deaths cause you guys probably aren't going to stfu.

im on board

vote barry


out of everyone that has posted in the first 80 posts, he's the scummiest link.

this would be the posts im referring to.

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Showtime im also curious what your updated read on barry since you did vote him prior to leaving last night

 

[Poyser]

tbf i think magic's answer to me tracks with him reading jeff town. what hes saying makes sense

 

[Showtime]

Ok, can you read some of my back and forth with tweet and tell me what you think? Dont need to go through all of it as we retread a lot of the same ground but at least the early stuff

im on post 221.

i was legit about reading on from where i left off as that's what i was doing last year as town and i did well with it. i don't do well when i try to skip shit to be 'caught up' while missing all the context and stuff in between. i prefer it my way because i can still see what's happening in the present tense and match it up with what people said earlier and seeing if it makes sense that they've arrived at their current position based on what they were saying earlier.

day 2 will be a good day if this continues, how about that?

^also based on this i'd rather just have jeff lynched.

i'll phrase it like this, do you really think odo is putting in a town role that massively ramps up in power, every phase, just by accumulating votes? as town the risk is basically free because you just ask for it whereas as non-town the risk is actually there to let either gain abilities or hide low.

this is much like my yu-gi-oh role where i had to complete certain actions to gain roles.

"
Congratulations, you have acquired the Millennium Ring!

You may now kill on non consecutive nights.

Your next task is to obtain the Millennium Rod by either lynching the bearer, or killing them at night. If they are killed by other means, you may still visit the corpse ... "

^^

do you have any reason for why we shouldn't just lynch jeff and actually go on with this madness past day 1?

 

[Comrade Khan]

tbf i think magic's answer to me tracks with him reading jeff town. what hes saying makes sense

i looked a bit further into his posts from last night and he pretty much states hes on page 7 and leaves shortly after. so im not really seeing a slip as barry put it here either.

 

[Comrade Khan]

im on post 221.

i was legit about reading on from where i left off as that's what i was doing last year as town and i did well with it. i don't do well when i try to skip shit to be 'caught up' while missing all the context and stuff in between. i prefer it my way because i can still see what's happening in the present tense and match it up with what people said earlier and seeing if it makes sense that they've arrived at their current position based on what they were saying earlier.



^also based on this i'd rather just have jeff lynched.

i'll phrase it like this, do you really think odo is putting in a town role that massively ramps up in power, every phase, just by accumulating votes? as town the risk is basically free because you just ask for it whereas as non-town the risk is actually there to let either gain abilities or hide low.

this is much like my yu-gi-oh role where i had to complete certain actions to gain roles.

"
Congratulations, you have acquired the Millennium Ring!

You may now kill on non consecutive nights.

Your next task is to obtain the Millennium Rod by either lynching the bearer, or killing them at night. If they are killed by other means, you may still visit the corpse ... "

^^

do you have any reason for why we shouldn't just lynch jeff and actually go on with this madness past day 1?

nah thats not what im hinting at role wise brev. will happily show you tomorrow too

 

[RDK]

Sorry I'm late

He did this a few times as scum last game too

can you provide receipts for this so it's clear you're not just being opportunistic here?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

i looked a bit further into his posts from last night and he pretty much states hes on page 7 and leaves shortly after. so im not really seeing a slip as barry put it here either.

Nah I don't really think his thoughts line up perfectly. He could clarify things a little further or y'know, dumb shit down so even I, an idiot, can understand.