Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Alco]

I don't get what you and Haza are on about with this tbh.

Literally on page 3 he says



so the idea that the man wasn't pushing his role BEFORE he was sussed is silly.

I don't really think there's any question he has the role or something similar to it tbh, it's something that is surely provable down the line and quite simply an unnecessarily risky thing to claim d1 if not true.

The real argument against Jeff is that the role could be any alignment; I know I shouldn't get into indy spec this early but it's certainly not outside the realm of responsibility that Odo - the brains behind my Indie Hel mechanic - would be giving an Indy Jeff this sort of role.

I probably misinterpreted that post then or just completely glossed over it. I just think his first couple of pages were very, very uninspiring.

 

[Poyser]

I don't know, but gun to my head probably not. His logic right now feels off, but he's also playing really offense which doesn't feel like scum Tweet, but I've also not played many with him when he's scum I don't think.

How is he playing offence? I don’t even think he’s voting anybody at the time you said this lol

 

[Poyser]

So yeah I can't really be assed to talk more about that topic, I realize my logic is probably all over the place but talking over it in circles is leading nowhere, if people wanna lynch me over that feel free, but Ima move on to other places now.

I still don't like Smarks explanation for his Jeff vote, I think Barry is just being opportunistic and voting whereever the wind is blowing, and Hazas entrance was also big meh. I could spell out meta reasons for why I think it's likely he's scum here but I don't like flat out talking about peoples meta anymore cause they just adapt too quickly. Let's just say he comes across as very forced and tryhard.

 

[Poyser]

poyser isn't trying super hard 2 seconds into the game.

likely town.


THIS IS ONE.


also shut the fuck up, you don't need 100 posts.

you too jeff

and smark

and whoever else has 60+.

All my posts are fantastic tho

 

[Poyser]

Tweet you’ve apparently got 3 scum reads why just unvote when one of them is on 3? Did your read change? Even if so, why not vote one of your other scum reads?

 

[Poyser]

But the whole “I’ve got meta reasons for reading him scum but I’m not gonna elaborate in case he adapts” is no buys lmao

also if you’re actually town then that’s some pussy ass shit

 

[Poyser]

I will try and shut up a bit though because I’m outposting jeff ffs

 

[Poyser]

Is it though? I think I've seen Tweet refuse to claim as town before

I think the most damning point in your case is that he was acting like you also knew what he was suspecting and I don't seem to find a proper defense of him to that point.

He has refused to claim as town yeah but only when he thinks his wagon is shit, wasn’t really something he implied here

 

[Poyser]

vote haza
I’ll help here tho for now as I agree his logic with the jeff thing didn’t really track

 

[Alco]

Readback over

1. Haza
2. Alco
3. T'Challa
4. Poyser
5. Ace
6. Tweet
7. Big Man
8. Barry
9. Smark
10. Brutus
11. Blaine
12. CP
13. Magic
14. Kajuh
15. Jeff
16. Doddsy
17. Lethal
18. TKOK
19. Phenom
20. Chimp
21. Flay

where I'm at.
Haza had similar thoughts to mine, I don't see what Big Man's seeing tbh.
Poyser's push on Tweet feels genuine. CP was jokey at first but the vote on Jeff and subsequent posts made me think his intentions are GOOD.
Smark's backtrack and apparent lack of commitment make me feel uneasy. Jeff's posts pre-vote-campaign sit badly with me and while the role might be legit, I'm not sure if it's alignment indicative per se . I can also see a world in which Smark and Jeff are aligned.
Very unsure about the Tweety baby. I think I liked him better as the game progressed, but can't shake the feeling that Poy was bang on with his initial assessment . The claim does nothing either.

 

[Alco]

vote haza
I’ll help here tho for now as I agree his logic with the jeff thing didn’t really track

Damn I don't really understand lol. I remember reading Haza's post and be like "yea I'm thinking the same thing"

 

[Alco]

Also both Jeff and Tweet being yellow is annoying, cause at the same time I can't see them being aligned

 

[Ace]

Nah it means I can't explain very well why I think he looks better than he usually does. Just seems to me the PR allows him to post more freely somehow.

What does Occams Razor have to do with this? I have a very poor memory of past games.

Yeah well that whimsical answer kinda doesn't sit well with me tbh.
Occams Razor = the simplest answer is most likely the right one.

 

[Poyser]

Damn I don't really understand lol. I remember reading Haza's post and be like "yea I'm thinking the same thing"

For me I don’t really understand why he would express caution just like I said at the time lol. So he wants to be voted, and? I even asked him what possible role would mean we have to be cautious and he had nothing so it’s not even like he had something in mind lol, which means it’s probably just virtue signalling, kinda like how for some reason scum keep telling us to watch for the executioner and thinking that’s a good tactic

 

[Ace]

But the whole “I’ve got meta reasons for reading him scum but I’m not gonna elaborate in case he adapts” is no buys lmao

also if you’re actually town then that’s some pussy ass shit

Yeah it's super weird - like "My reasons for him are meta so I won't give them... but here is my reason" where the reason he gives is super vague.

Feels like Tweet doesn't have true reasons and is instead trying to create vague fake reasons to feign activity.

Vote Tweet