Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

@Raidokken when you said "are you not town," I immediately pmed Odo is he not a survivor?

 

[Showtime]

It also makes bussing plays extremely difficult to counteract

learn to read bussing

 

[Smart Marx]

I think it’s the part where smark is universally scum rea, claims to bodyguard someone who is ... firmly in poe shall we say, and then the thread responds by taking them both out of poe with no further question

I mean Magic coming in and saying he saw me was just the greatest luck. The thread couldn't have known Jeff suspected he might be watcher.

 

[Ace]

I think it’s the part where smark is universally scum rea, claims to bodyguard someone who is ... firmly in poe shall we say, and then the thread responds by taking them both out of poe with no further question

Also this.

I'm not saying you guys should have necessarily even won, and tbf you were one of the few who were actively still considering that Smark/Jeff could be scum so the frustration is not really directed at you so much.

 

[Tweet]

Yeah no listen Flay's last day shenanigans I can completely sympathise with you guys on. The only thing I could possibly counter on is that Flay is known to troll like this (I remember Flay admitting to being scum and getting lynched... only to flip town). But even so it's complete bullshit.

Lylo thing is less cut and dry, it was pretty exceptional circumstances tbf and admittedly I'm not sure Jeff's role was perfectly designed but on that I can give benefit of the doubt.

Yeah obviously it's known that Flay has potential to make fake info plays but that fact alone is nauseating to play around.

 

[Smart Marx]

I think the thread took Jeff out because at first it seemed like I stopped a kill on him, but when Magic did see me they forget he wasn't saved anymore.

 

[Ace]

Yeah obviously it's known that Flay has potential to make fake info plays but that fact alone is nauseating to play around.

Completely agreed. I was surprised she was allowed to play again after the old shenanigans tbh

 

[Showtime]

Yeah I think I'm mostly frustrated that we got properly cleaned up and had our arses handed to us early, then somehow town just let Smark and Jeff cruise through with little trouble for basically no reason.
Like I totally get mistakes and shit but the fact that they were basically given free reign to lead town was tough to me. Particularly given the result sequence where Smark was seen at Jeff didn't really make sense iirc.

I'm shitting on town but I was also pretty bad, fell into the same scum meta I had used to win before and made the parallels easy to draw.

i dont think you played bad. people bought your defense and outside of myself you were no one else's priority lol.

 

[Odo]

Anyway, thanks everyone for playing and apologies to anyone who has been left frustrated - this wasn’t the best game I’ve ever hosted and I haven’t really enjoyed any aspect of it, but Godspeed

 

[Tweet]

Why did the watcher not see the person who shot Jeff?
There was a missing kill and the general suggestion was that Smark had protected Jeff (Smark even said you're welcome and people went along with it).

I didn't believe that Smark had protected against a kill tbh, the visit itself was enough for me to make his claim seem more credible.

 

[Comrade Khan]

i mean fwiw i was only in INDY poe. once haza died no one was ever lynching me. no one even brought my name up lol

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I think WTF Moment of the Year goes to that faked info tbh.

 

[Ace]

i dont think you played bad. people bought your defense and outside of myself you were no one else's priority lol.

From my own perspective I kept realising in hindsight that I was slipping into habits I should be trying to avoid.

I do think without you I would have survived a fair bit longer though lol.

 

[Showtime]

I mean Magic coming in and saying he saw me was just the greatest luck. The thread couldn't have known Jeff suspected he might be watcher.

btw, if you guys left me alive i would have gone after you as there was no good reason to leave a potential bg alive over anyone else. the kill targets at night should have been a hint as to who scum was.

 

[Chloe B]