Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[CraigPelton]

The problem I have is I feel like he wasn't openly scumming at all until CP and Poyser starting voting for him. If he was being genuine about wanting votes right now why would that transition only come once he started to be called out?

That's what I'd like to know about it!

 

[Smart Marx]

Yeah the more I read that tweet post the more it stinks

The one where he's voting for you?

 

[Comrade Khan]

yay were getting somewhere lol

 

[Tweet]

Yeah the more I read that tweet post the more it stinks

Feel free to place your vote, the way it is this might be considered shading and waiting to see whether the room agrees or not

 

[Smart Marx]

So faking it isn’t an option in your mind? wonder why

Would you suspect scum to bus or protect Jeff with what he's doing rn if he was scum?

 

[CraigPelton]

As part of the room I agree

 

[Tweet]

So faking it isn’t an option in your mind? wonder why

No it isn't because I'm thinking - why the fuck would he?

 

[Smart Marx]

No it isn't because I'm thinking - why the fuck would he?

At first I thought maybe when he he said pre-emptively he wouldn't claim, but this whole thing feels elaborate for no reason.

 

[Poyser]

The one where he's voting for you?

Yeah. It’s kinda like the post I got haza on last game (tho not quite as obviously full of shit)

he chose a narrative and stuck to it rather than give a genuine reply. He decided he wanted to paint me as scummy so he said both of the options i presented were designed to shade him (implying I never gave him the option to be town). However if you think about it for even 5 seconds me calling his actions dumb as opposed to scummy would be to imply that he’s town....

also yeah I don’t really see the angle with why me pushing jeff when he’s asking for votes would be scummy. I dont really see the logic there, do you?

 

[Tweet]

Kay I suppose I oughta speak more openly then.

I thought Jeff was sitting on a very strong role and wanted to get wagoned so he could pull out his claim and then go "awwwright let's see who's scum on this wagon then", but if he artificially creates a wagon like that with deliberately sketchy play, the wagon isn't gonna be worth much.

 

[RDK]

That's what I'd like to know about it!

Good to hear someone is sharing my reservations my great friend. Heres to the two of us enjoying another prosperous outing!

 

[CraigPelton]

So is jeff gonna claim or is this phase gonna be all about him and his summer camp secret that tweet thinks he knows what it is even though he didn't go to camp that summer and doesn't run in the same friend circles

 

[Poyser]

Feel free to place your vote, the way it is this might be considered shading and waiting to see whether the room agrees or not

I mean, feel free to take that swing if ya want pal. Hopefully you’ll do a better job this time around

 

[Smart Marx]

Yeah. It’s kinda like the post I got haza on last game (tho not quite as obviously full of shit)

he chose a narrative and stuck to it rather than give a genuine reply. He decided he wanted to paint me as scummy so he said both of the options i presented were designed to shade him (implying I never gave him the option to be town). However if you think about it for even 5 seconds me calling his actions dumb as opposed to scummy would be to imply that he’s town....

also yeah I don’t really see the angle with why me pushing jeff when he’s asking for votes would be scummy. I dont really see the logic there, do you?

I don't see how it's shady or scummy, either. Even before he asked for votes, he made some questionable pre-emptive posts.

 

[Poyser]

Would you suspect scum to bus or protect Jeff with what he's doing rn if he was scum?

I wouldn’t expect them to be aligned. It would be tweet as scum, knowing jeff is town