Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Showtime]

I kinda want Magic dead though because he was really attaching himself to Doddsy hard.

ill refrain from being mean


you know youre the vig. you have the explicitly told to you.

i do not have this information.

with the information i have and the hints doddsy made, it was a reasonable conclusion that doddsy would be vig.

that's not attaching myself hard, that's making conclusions with the info i see.

what exactly do you think the scum motivation is there?

 

[Showtime]

So I'm still confused on Chimp. I know everyone is saying he's town because of the duel and apparently he's just playing how he normally does, but nothing about him has seemed town to me. I've never played with him before so I don't know what he's usually like. First of all, he killed Brutus and he also voted Tweet (and asked the vig to kill him) and they were both town. Now he's voting Jeff with his only reason being "I trust Doddsy" and this stood out to me because Jeff is one of my town leans. All of it just seems very reckless as town

chimp is shit and plays like shit and it's hard to read him as you would read other players because he basically plays like shit. it is all quite reckless as town, you're not wrong.

 

[Poyser]

Seriously what the fuck Poyser? At least let Doddsy talk so I can potentially catch him in a lie.

Lol come on mate

 

[Comrade Khan]

tbf assuming doddsy was vig was a bit generous as he explicitly said his role was scummy on d1. unless u think that was just for fun he said that

 

[Poyser]

Any other thoughts kajuh? What do you think about magic, alco and ace?

 

[Kajuh]

chimp is shit and plays like shit and it's hard to read him as you would read other players because he basically plays like shit. it is all quite reckless as town, you're not wrong.

That also seems to be the consensus lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

which I must say is a bit of an oversight for magic, suppose he could have missed it on read back/forgot as that was super early on d1 iirc

 

[Showtime]

tbf assuming doddsy was vig was a bit generous as he explicitly said his role was scummy on d1. unless u think that was just for fun he said that

no i just forgot about that. he said it on page 1, but indicating one of you or chimp is scum made me think he had a killing role because role overlap makes the most sense for that conclusion to be made.

 

[Poyser]

I forgot tbh

I didn’t think Doddsy was hinting at vig either tho

 

[Comrade Khan]

no i just forgot about that. he said it on page 1, but indicating one of you or chimp is scum made me think he had a killing role because role overlap makes the most sense for that conclusion to be made.

yeh i somewhat ninjad you. hmmm

 

[Poyser]

Right well if Doddsy does have a killing role then there probably definitely is scum in jeff and chimp lol (or indy whatever)

 

[Smart Marx]

tbf assuming doddsy was vig was a bit generous as he explicitly said his role was scummy on d1. unless u think that was just for fun he said that

Good catch.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I forgot tbh

I didn’t think Doddsy was hinting at vig either tho

I mean yeah im not really sure how being the vig would mean a 1x daykiller or a 1x duellist HAS to be scum

 

[Comrade Khan]

Right well if Doddsy does have a killing role then there probably definitely is scum in jeff and chimp lol (or indy whatever)

or doddsy is lol. not like hes not known for setting up town with fake info or wtv.

 

[Showtime]

I mean yeah im not really sure how being the vig would mean a 1x daykiller or a 1x duellist HAS to be scum

i mean i still think it's sus that there's 3 town killing abilities, it's a lot but we dont know what scum has to counter/what the indy roles are/is.