KingMaker II Game Thread

[RetepAdam.]

Maybe I'm the only one that just-

The more Jeff talks about this certain topic, the more sketchy I feel on him.

Having literally a full quarter of the game's posts as scum would be quite the flex.

 

[RetepAdam.]

But yeah, I assumed we were all vanilla.

Take that for what it's worth.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Now this makes me question Jeff even more tbh.

The newer players likely did not know that there would be extra player roles, and thus wouldn't be keen to shoot Doddsy based on that logic. I mean most of us assumed it was vanilla.

I'm not sure how putting myself in scums shoes and exploring options is a cause for concern, any good town player shouldn't assume anything unless it's explicitly in the op

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Having literally a full quarter of the game's posts as scum would be quite the flex.

Jeff has done this the last two scum games he mvp'd in.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I'm not sure how putting myself in scums shoes and exploring options is a cause for concern, any good town player shouldn't assume anything unless it's explicitly in the op

It's moreover like you're talking about something that's a distraction since there's zero reason to assume there's any power roles yet this early in the game, regardless if they were in the game last time, especially on a game this small atm.

 

[Jobber Doink]

I'm not sure how putting myself in scums shoes and exploring options is a cause for concern, any good town player shouldn't assume anything unless it's explicitly in the op

Aren't you doing the same thing by assuming their are power roles so mafia might be hunting for them?

 

[RetepAdam.]

That's plausibly a scum slip.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I mean Im mostly confused as what's problematic in my thought process here, last kimgmaker game had roles so obviously I'd consider that in my kill choices in the hypothetical situation as scum. The opposite would be concerning because then I would be ignoring my own experience. Perhaps we're in disagreement on semantics, as I was also simply exploring one of many possibilities as to why doddsy was murdered .

 

[Canadian Dragon]

But...Barry you're the one focusing on it by asking me more about it i feel we're going in circles a bit on this

 

[Canadian Dragon]

And I'm ultimately agreeing with you that cp looks poopy and your explanation is still valid for the doddsy kill. I was simply offering one of many possibilities that flew three my brain

 

[Sister Abigail]

I saw that there was a role called Hero in Kingmaker I. Thought that might be in here and maybe one more role but first game looked pretty Vanilla to me.

 

[RetepAdam.]

I mean Im mostly confused as what's problematic in my thought process here, last kimgmaker game had roles so obviously I'd consider that in my kill choices in the hypothetical situation as scum. The opposite would be concerning because then I would be ignoring my own experience. Perhaps we're in disagreement on semantics, as I was also simply exploring one of many possibilities as to why doddsy was murdered .

The Kingmaker game Chris linked to didn't have roles, though.

Where that assumption of yours came from feels like an important sticking point.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

The Kingmaker game Chris linked to didn't have roles, though.

Where that assumption of yours came from feels like an important sticking point.

It did tho?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Am I imagining a different game I specifically read a scum flip that had a sneaky assassin n the end game I complained about town roles . I'm legit confused now of I'm mixing up games

 

[Jobber Doink]

Am I imagining a different game I specifically read a scum flip that had a sneaky assassin n the end game I complained about town roles . I'm legit confused now of I'm mixing up games

Go to bed.