KingMaker I Game Thread

[Alco]

All these names man. Okay Brandalorian can go in light blue as well then.

Jeff, I thought you were floating about during a fair bit of the first phase, even after the content was picking up (at least that's how I observed it). Also, as King, sitting back and letting the rest decide the kill for you looks to be a comfortable position to be in if you were scum (I will consede that some were calling for a "collaborative king" early on, which is why my name was brought up as well somehow)

 

[Smart Marx]

hmmm, you did mention that earlier didn't you. We can't have MP execute himself though. Who was his other choice?

I did, and while we can't kill MP this phase just keep it in mind. Bug Man was the backup so that might clear him. Might.

Unless they were two steps ahead of us, but that's just WIFOM on WIFOM and I'd rather just give BM a slight town read.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I'm not saying Rugrat is town or anything, just that Jeff seemed to be the only one who felt Rugrat was sussy at a time he was being pretty readily read town.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Tbh, you never explained your reasoning as to why you sus Rugrat or Sky. Sky is basically confirmed at this point so it's moot, but this early in the game what made you suspect of Rug?





Tweet saying he trusts Rugrat, but you suss him.





This felt pretty forced to get a sussy read on Rugrat tbh.



But the person you trusted most, Tweet, felt Rugrat was town at this juncture, but you never changed your read. I dunno. Just felt like you were trying to lean town towards Rugrat as the first kill.

where are you even going with this? You're whole point falls apart when you realize that he never town read Rugrat at any point, just that he would trust himto be king. Big fucking difference lol.

Tweet also refused to town read Smark. Just because Tweet had different reads than me on day 1 doesn't really mean anything

What is you're actual point here?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'm not saying Rugrat is town or anything, just that Jeff seemed to be the only one who felt Rugrat was sussy at a time he was being pretty readily read town.

Yeah I'm going to need some fucking receipts that Rugrat was readily town read, because you sir, are full of shit.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

where are you even going with this? You're whole point falls apart when you realize that he never town read Rugrat at any point, just that he would trust himto be king. Big fucking difference lol.

Tweet also refused to town read Smark. Just because Tweet had different reads than me on day 1 doesn't really mean anything

What is you're actual point here?

Erm. Yes he did.

I rate Rugrats list slightly town, activity and composure and being agreeable are good criteria by which to choose the first king and the list makes sense in that regard, but putting that together is something anyone can do as any alignment. While I don't think that list tells any lies about the players involved in order to nudge the kingmaker into making scum king, I also don't think there's a huge amount of value in scum being made king d1.

That's a town read, even if it's slight.

 

[Comrade Khan]

All these names man. Okay Brandalorian can go in light blue as well then.

Jeff, I thought you were floating about during a fair bit of the first phase, even after the content was picking up (at least that's how I observed it). Also, as King, sitting back and letting the rest decide the kill for you looks to be a comfortable position to be in if you were scum (I will consede that some were calling for a "collaborative king" early on, which is why my name was brought up as well somehow)

I was asked and bitched at on day 0 that I could go rogue. so I didn't. Kind of hard to push my own direction when I can't slam a vote down to do along with it. If you guys would have rather me be a heavy handed tyrant and push my reads harder I can.

That being said, had I pushed my read, it turns out I would have died too :/

 

[Comrade Khan]

Erm. Yes he did.



That's a town read, even if it's slight.

That's a far cry from readily town read bud.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Yeah I'm going to need some fucking receipts that Rugrat was readily town read, because you sir, are full of shit.

Okay, Sky and Tweet both had slight town reads on him. The two people that have turned out to be the most trustworthy at this juncture. Not only that, I believe he was actively doing good for town, so he had a town read from me at the time as well. I think Smark may have town read him at one point too.

 

[Rugrat]

Jeff is an interesting one. I’m still baffled by him killing Barry. He probably wanted to kill me but didn’t have the stones to without town’s support -so opted for the Bobcat or Sky.

I would like to know why he didn’t push Sky for the kill, instead of Barry

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Either way, Jeff's case on me is just as shit, tbh.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

So to be clear though:

My push on Jeff is based off his interaction during N0 and D1 and Jeff's principal push on me has to do with OMGUS and also the fact I happened to rep in.

I dunno man, seems like Jeff honestly has nothing.

 

[Rugrat]

I’m liking Bobcat v2.

Again, Jeff; why did you execute Barry over Skybox?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I’m liking Bobcat v2.

Again, Jeff; why did you execute Barry over Skybox?

2 reasons.

1 - sky hinted a role, which she has now confirmed.
2 - At the time, Barry was doing nothing but taunting me (except for the last maybe 15 minutes). It was between the two of them when we had lil time left.

Pretty easy choice to be honest, why would I lynch someone who has hinted a role and is actively playing over someone who's being a dipshit in thread and bringing literally nothing to the table?

If you can answer that for me, I'll yield it was a bad choice.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Either way, there should be a fair amount of directions to go in here. If you're dumb enough to buy barry's shit case, it's going to be an easy win for scum once smark also eats a bullet and the thread dies