KingMaker I Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

Either way, there should be a fair amount of directions to go in here. If you're dumb enough to buy barry's shit case, it's going to be an easy win for scum once smark also eats a bullet and the thread dies

I have to say, though, I don't like your reasons for killing Barry. I'll keep saying this, but he seemed staunchly town Barry.

 

[Comrade Khan]

1. Jeffatron
2. Ace Dalton Char Aznable v2.0
3. Alco
4. Brandalorian
5. V.Sky
6. Big Man
7. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
8. Rugrat
10. Juice
12. MyPrerogative

So 50%-ish of the field logically should be scum once you take out the town reads.

MP can't be lynched, so that's out of the question today.

Leaves BM, JUICE, Buffy, Alco and Barry.

Which means at LEAST 2 of them are scum (possibly 3, saying at least 2 since MP could logically also be scum)

 

[Smart Marx]

1. Jeffatron
2. Ace Dalton Char Aznable v2.0
3. Alco
4. Brandalorian
5. V.Sky
6. Big Man
7. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
8. Rugrat
10. Juice
12. MyPrerogative

So 50%-ish of the field logically should be scum once you take out the town reads.

MP can't be lynched, so that's out of the question today.

Leaves BM, JUICE, Buffy, Alco and Barry.

Which means at LEAST 2 of them are scum (possibly 3, saying at least 2 since MP could logically also be scum)

I would rule out BM today. I don't like that scum could have killed MP and had BM be the king and didn't if he was scum.

 

[Rugrat]

I have to say, though, I don't like your reasons for killing Barry. I'll keep saying this, but he seemed staunchly town Barry.

He was being a provocateur, which never goes down well. I guess it seemed a choice of him and Skybox, apparently Skybawks has a role????

So he didn’t have much choice

 

[Rugrat]

I would rule out BM today. I don't like that scum could have killed MP and had BM be the king and didn't if he was scum.

That would make it look very obvious though.

 

[Smart Marx]

He was being a provocateur, which never goes down well. I guess it seemed a choice of him and Skybox, apparently Skybawks has a role????

So he didn’t have much choice

He could have killed an inactive, gambled on Sky since it's Sky and was being weird, you or anyone that wasn't a likely town flip.

 

[Smart Marx]

That would make it look very obvious though.

I don't think they were thinking that far ahead. I'm not ruling it out, just saying not today.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I have to say, though, I don't like your reasons for killing Barry. I'll keep saying this, but he seemed staunchly town Barry.

I mean reasons aside, it was still the right decision considering the other option was sky, which if we are to believe, means I would have died instead of her.

Perhaps I was a bit of a pussy regarding Rugrat, but again, if we assume Sky is town, that I have to assume now also that Rugrat is town.

Which means that logically, all three of our choices (4 if we include tweet as he was being sussed too) would have all flipped town

I don't see how my logic was off on the choice of barry regardless of your personal read on him. Had we had more time, and had he not played like a dunce for 95% of the phase, we could have perhaps made a better decision.

Who were his choices though yesterday btw?

 

[Smart Marx]

That would make it look very obvious though.

Because you have to remember, not only did they give up the choice of having the King on their team, but they also killed Tweet and conformed another townie for no reason. Seems like poor planning. I'd look elsewhere before coming back to BM.

MP is a better choice for the next day we can look at him.

 

[Smart Marx]

I mean reasons aside, it was still the right decision considering the other option was sky, which if we are to believe, means I would have died instead of her.

Perhaps I was a bit of a pussy regarding Rugrat, but again, if we assume Sky is town, that I have to assume now also that Rugrat is town.

Which means that logically, all three of our choices (4 if we include tweet as he was being sussed too) would have all flipped town

I don't see how my logic was off on the choice of barry regardless of your personal read on him. Had we had more time, and had he not played like a dunce for 95% of the phase, we could have perhaps made a better decision.

Who were his choices though yesterday btw?

Why are we acting like the only options were Sky and Barry? I'm really not liking you and Rugrat pushing this poor narrative tbh.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

1. Jeffatron
2. Ace Dalton Char Aznable v2.0
3. Alco
4. Brandalorian
5. V.Sky
6. Big Man
7. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
8. Rugrat
10. Juice
12. MyPrerogative

So 50%-ish of the field logically should be scum once you take out the town reads.

MP can't be lynched, so that's out of the question today.

Leaves BM, JUICE, Buffy, Alco and Barry.

Which means at LEAST 2 of them are scum (possibly 3, saying at least 2 since MP could logically also be scum)

Man, you just can't be any more wrong.

I keep saying I'd like to see you get me lynched. I wonder why.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I would rule out BM today. I don't like that scum could have killed MP and had BM be the king and didn't if he was scum.

I would probably not hang biggy TODAY either, if only because he actually might help us once he awakes from his low-activity slumber. He at least has the potential to be helpful?

 

[Smart Marx]

I don't see how my logic was off on the choice of barry regardless of your personal read on him.

Besides the fact I have a near 99.9% success rate at reading him when I have a strong read, he was being his classic town meta.

He's done the please kill me as I'm distracting town thing on day 1 like a dozen times.

 

[Smart Marx]

I would probably not hang biggy TODAY either, if only because he actually might help us once he awakes from his low-activity slumber. He at least has the potential to be helpful?

Considering he's played this style of game before, I'm kind of hoping he'll be helpful here pretty soon. If he's town.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Why are we acting like the only options were Sky and Barry? I'm really not liking you and Rugrat pushing this poor narrative tbh.

Go back and read the thread at the time. By the end of day, as far as I remember it, it was

Barry or sky

followed by susses on Rugrat and Tweet.

And I was staunchly against lynching tweet from n0...

Feel free to prove me wrong, but that's just a fact imo.

Are you going to have an actual direction and opinion though? It seems you're quite happy shooting down theories while not really offering a direction of your own.