KingMaker I Game Thread

[Worst Player Ever]

OK at this point - only Big Man, Buffy, and Juice haven't weighed in:

I'm not seeing Big Man as town, personally. Has done basically nothing all game. So if you want suspects, start there.

Well I was not quite happy with Sky's contributions Night 0, but the soft definitely gives me cause to pause.

The Big Man = scum because he's doing nothing-theory has been done to death though, imo. Not sure I want to attach any value to it. I'll try to look over his posts when I've got some time later this afternoon.

I was not feeling Jeff on N0/D1, if I recall correctly. Might be a good place to start. Also still convinced Smark is town, even though pretty much the only guy sussing him all game is now dead

Oh he's still alive. Alright.

MP should probably think about shooting Jeff then.

To me that's also a fairly optimal strategy. Shoot the previous king as the chances of scum/town are 50/50 and we'd learn more from their flip based on interactions with others.

okay so sky is town. I'll need to read back.

this version of Barry looks way better than his previous version. Fairly confident he's town. Actively looking to solve the game doesn't appear to be a scum trait of Barry's.

Sky probably town as well then, based on that claim.

Which leads me to Jeff I guess

Smark's activity seems to have taken a bit of a nosedive as well, though.

1. Jeffatron
2. Ace Dalton Char Aznable v2.0
3. Alco
4. Brandalorian
5. V.Sky
6. Big Man
7. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
8. Rugrat
10. Juice
12. MyPrerogative

Who's Smark on this list again? lel

I don't think I've seen anything out of Buffy and Brandalorian yet. Are they even playing?

Seems contradictory if she's the hero bodyguard after saying she wasn't, but sure.

Rugrat might be a good shout to look at now. I don't like the push on Barry at all.

He claimed Barry could be doing a Gambit, and then near the end of the phase said we should just kill him because we were tolerating his nonsense. Just a bad push when we know that's how town Barry acts like almost every time he's sussed day 1.

I don't have a read yet on current Barry, however. I'd need to see more from him today.

All these names man. Okay Brandalorian can go in light blue as well then.

Jeff, I thought you were floating about during a fair bit of the first phase, even after the content was picking up (at least that's how I observed it). Also, as King, sitting back and letting the rest decide the kill for you looks to be a comfortable position to be in if you were scum (I will consede that some were calling for a "collaborative king" early on, which is why my name was brought up as well somehow)

Jeff is an interesting one. I’m still baffled by him killing Barry. He probably wanted to kill me but didn’t have the stones to without town’s support -so opted for the Bobcat or Sky.

I would like to know why he didn’t push Sky for the kill, instead of Barry

I’m liking Bobcat v2.

Again, Jeff; why did you execute Barry over Skybox?

1. Jeffatron
2. Ace Dalton Char Aznable v2.0
3. Alco
4. Brandalorian
5. V.Sky
6. Big Man
7. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
8. Rugrat
10. Juice
12. MyPrerogative

So 50%-ish of the field logically should be scum once you take out the town reads.

MP can't be lynched, so that's out of the question today.

Leaves BM, JUICE, Buffy, Alco and Barry.

Which means at LEAST 2 of them are scum (possibly 3, saying at least 2 since MP could logically also be scum)

I would rule out BM today. I don't like that scum could have killed MP and had BM be the king and didn't if he was scum.

Why are we acting like the only options were Sky and Barry? I'm really not liking you and Rugrat pushing this poor narrative tbh.

Rugrat would have been a fine lynch if there were no other options. Barry is probably the only one that you shouldn't have.

If Sky flips town, I wouldn't have sussed you too hard for it considering I was questioning her soft too on day 1.

Yeah, you or Rugrat. I've been pretty clear that the people who lynched Barry on day 1 are to be looked at.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I know Lethal is a newer host, but an unlynchable kingmaker hero seems a bit much

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I know Lethal is a newer host, but an unlynchable kingmaker hero seems a bit much

So your guess is it does overwrite my role?

 

[Smart Marx]

I've got to be honest, it's not going to go the way you think if you pursue my direction. Because as of Tweet's death, I've actually been made the new Kingmaker.

I don't know if that overwrites my other role, but I wouldn't risk it if I were you.

Convenient. So why the backtrack on being the bodyguard?

 

[Comrade Khan]

So your guess is it does overwrite my role?

Having never played this setup, with a newer host, I honestly have no idea. I suppose we could wait for a counter claim as well.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Convenient. So why the backtrack on being the bodyguard?

I never even hinted at BG. Not once.

 

[Smart Marx]

I never even hinted at BG. Not once.

You just just claimed you were the hero bodyguard.

What are you even doing anymore?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

You just just claimed you were the hero bodyguard.

What are you even doing anymore?

No I didn't. You're being confused. MP's stance was that hero+BG were two different roles held by two different people and you've misinterpreted that.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Smark is very clearly shading for the sake of shading at this point, and should be in serious consideration for the kill.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I highly doubt Sky is the bodyguard.

 

[Smart Marx]

No I didn't. You're being confused. MP's stance was that hero+BG were two different roles held by two different people and you've misinterpreted that.

You never clarified the difference. You simply said you were the thing MP was talking about.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

You never clarified the difference. You simply said you were the thing MP was talking about.

Because the difference was obvious to anyone who wasn't wilfully twisting others' words to get a lynch.

MP/Smark not co-scum

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I highly doubt Sky is the bodyguard.

Well, no shit.

 

[Smart Marx]

I highly doubt Sky is the bodyguard.

She’s saying that now, anyway. So she’s definitely not.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Well, no shit.

No back sass, missy.