KIF's star ratings(May contain spoilers)

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE SmackDown 1/24:
Roman Reigns & The Usos v.s Dolph Ziggler, Robert Roode & Baron Corbin ***14
Elias & Braun Strowman v.s Cesaro & Shinsuke Nakamura *1/2
Kofi Kingston v.s John Morrison **1/4

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE Raw 1/27:
Drew McIntyre v.s O.C. *
Rey Mysterio v.s MVP Damn
Kenneth Jones v.s Aleister Black 1/4*
Tag Team Titles Match: Seth Rollins & Buddy Murphy(c) v.s Kevin Owens & Samoa Joe ***1/2
US Title Match: Andrade(c) v.s Humerto Carrillo ***
Charlotte Flair v.s Asuka **1/2
24/7 Title: Mojo Rawlay v.s No Way Jose N/A
Branden Vice v.s Erick Rowan 1/4*


WWE Raw 2/3:
Mojo Rawley v.s Drew McIntyre 1/4*
Elimination Match: Kevin Owens & The Viking Raiders v.s Buddy Murphy & AOP **1/4
Eric Young v.s Aleister Black 1/2*
Angel Garza v.s Rey Mysterio **
Asuka v.s Natayla **1/2
#1 Contendership for the World Title: Seth Rollins v.s Ricochet v.s Bobby Lashley *3/4

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE SmackDown 2/14:
SD Women’s Title Match: Carmella v.s Bayley(c) **1/2
Sheamus v.s Apollo Crews & Shorty G *1/4
Miz & Morrison v.s Roman Reigns & Daniel Bryan **3/4


WWE Raw 2/17:
Erick Rowan v.s Aleister Black ***
24/7 Title Match: Mojo Rawley v.s R-Truth v.s Riddick Moss(c) If you say so
Drew McIntyre v.s MVP 1/2*
Rusev & Humber Carrillo v.s Lashley & Angel Garza **1/2
Natalya v.s Kairi Sane Weak
Karl Anderson v.s Ricochet *1/4
Viking Raiders & Kevin Owens v.s AOP & Buddy Murphy ***1/4

I may not have every show completely rated but I am currently caught up on main WWE shows. Remember to ask for specific matches if I miss them.

Edit: I will mention though the 8-man tag from the Raw prior I have at 4 stars.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE Super Showdown:

Tuwaiq Trophy Guantlet: R-Truth v.s Bobby Lashley v.s Andrade v.s Eric Rowan v.s AJ Styles v.s The Undertaker *3/4


SD! Tag Team Titles Match: Miz & Morrison v.s The New Day(c) ***1/2


Angel Garza v.s Humberto Carrillo ***1/2


Raw Tag Team Titles Match: Murphy & Seth Rollins(c) v.s Street Profits **3/4


Dolph Ziggler v.s Mansoor **1/2


WWE Title Match: Ricochet v.s Brock Lesnar(c) *


Steel Cage Match: King Corbin v.s Roman Reigns **1/2-**3/4


SD! Women’s Title Match: Naomi v.s Bayley(c) *3/4


Universal Title Match: Goldberg v.s The Fiend(c) Wow




WWE Raw 3/3:


Raw Tag Team Titles Match: Street Profits v.s Murphy & Seth Rollins(c) ***


24/7 Title Match: Riddick Moss(c) v.s Ricochet *1/4


Karl Anderson v.s Aleister Black 1/2*-3/4*


Luke Gallows v.s Aleister Black *


A.J. Styles v.s Aleister Black *


Special Guest Referee, Sarah Logan: Liv Morgan v.s Ruby Riot *1/4


Kairi Sane v.s Shayna Baszler Abstract


Rey Mysterio & Humberto Carrillo v.s Andrade & Angel Garza ***3/4


Elimination Chamber best match Gulak/Bryan ****

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE 2010:


WWE SmackDown 1/1:
Beat The Clock: CM Punk v.s Matt Hardy *3/4
Beat The Clock: KANE v.s Dolph Ziggler **-**1/4
The Carolina Panther v.s The Great Khali 1/4*
IC Title Match: John Morrison v.s Drew McIntyre *1/4
Beth Phoenix v.s Mickie James 1/4*
Beat The Clock: Chris Jericho v.s Rey Mysterio **3/4
Beat The Clock: R-Truth v.s Batista *1/2


WWE Raw 1/ 4:
Divas Title Tournament: Maryse v.s Brie Bella Eh
#1 Contendership for the US Title: MVP v.s Jack Swagger v.s Carlito v.s Mark Henry *
Unified Tag Team Title Match: DX(c) v.s JeriShow ***
Sheamus v.s Evan Bourne 3/4*
Kofi Kingston v.s Randy Orton Precedent


WWE ECW 1/5:
ECW Homecomin’ Qualifier: Shelton Benjamin v.s Chavo Guerrero **
Ezekiel Jackson v.s Vladimir Kozlov *
CM Punk v.s Mark Henry *1/4


WWE SmackDown 1/8:
KANE v.s Dolph Ziggler **
R-Truth & Cryme Tyme v.s Hart Dynasty & Chris Jericho *3/4
Luke Gallows v.s Matt Hardy *1/2
Beth Phoenix v.s Layla 1/4*
#1 Contendership for the WHC: Rey Mysterio v.s Batista Fine

 

[Chris]

Out of curiosity what did you rate the ladder match from 09 between DX and Jerishow? I thought those two teams put on some really good matches.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Man, I haven't watched that since it happened but I remember likin' it quite a bit. I'd probably say it was ***3/4 but I'd have to rewatch it again. Ladder matches without spot monkeys generally get higher ratings from me.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE 2010

WWE Raw 1/11:
Diva’s Title Tournament Match?: Kelly Kelly v.s Alicia Fox 1/2*
Legacy v.s Mark Henry & Evan Bourne *
Over The Top Challenge: Jack Swagger v.s Santino Marella These Potatoes Suck
#1 Contendership for the WWE Title: Randy Orton v.s Kofi Kingston v.s John Cena **
Diva’s Title Tournament Match?: Katie Lea v.s Eve 3/4*
DX v.s Chris Jericho & Mike Tyson History


WWE ECW Homecomin’ 1/12:
Zack Ryder v.s The Hurricane Hurri-out of shape
Goldust v.s Trent Barreta *1/2
ECW Homecomin’ Battle Royal: Ezekiel Jackson N/A


I don't rate battle royals or Royal Rumbles if anybody didn't know. You could give a shitty wrestler a great ratin' or a great wrestler who does damn well a terrible ratin'. It's not fair

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE SmackDown 1/15:
Chris Jericho v.s John Morrison **1/2
#1 Contendership for the Unified Tag Team Titles: CM Punk & Luke Gallows v.s Great Khali & Matt Hardy v.s Hart Dynasty v.s Cryme Tyme *
Mickie James v.s Beth Phoenix *1/2
KANE v.s Dolph Ziggler ***1/4
#1 Contendership for the WHC, Cage Match: Rey Mysterio v.s Batista **1/2

That was an awesome show. Tell me KANE/Ziggler sucks, they have some odd chemistry that works

 

[Chris]

I think you can rate rumbles and battle royale fine without it counting as a factor either way on wrestlers star rating history, I mean great wrestlers have been involved in plenty of shitty singles matches with WOAT booking anyway.

Most kind of run together for me anyway so I don't really care about you rating battle royals but I would love to see Rumble ratings

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE 2010

WWE Raw 1/18:
Evan Bourne v.s Sheamus Fun
Over The Top Challenge: Jack Swagger v.s Mark Henry Okay
John Cena & Kofi Kingston v.s Legacy *3/4
Maryse & Alicia Fox v.s Gail Kim & Eve *-*1/4
Randy Orton v.s Chris Masters 1/2*
ShowMiz & Jon Heder v.s DX & Hornswoggle Why?

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE ECW 1/19:
Yoshi Tatsu & Goldust v.s Trent Barreta & Caylen Croft *3/4
Christian v.s William Regal **3/4

The DQ finish made me sad. Christian and Regal are great together

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE SmackDown 1/22:
Batista v.s Finlay 3/4*
Drew McIntyre & Chris Jericho v.s John Morrison & R-Truth **1/2
Mike Knox & Charlie Haas v.s Cryme Tyme KANE
The Great Khali & Matt Hardy v.s Hart Dynasty 3/4*


WWE Raw2/25:
DX v.s Legacy **
MVP v.s Big Show Well
Divas Title Semi-Finals: Maryse v.s Eve *
The Miz(c) v.s Kofi Kingston *1/4
Gail Kim v.s Alicia Fox 1/2*-3/4*
WWE Title Match: Sheamus v.s John Cena *3/4

 

[Chris]

The last days of WWECW

 

[Kiffy Lube]

WWE Wrestlemania 36 Night 1:
Women's Tag Team Title Match: Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross v.s Kabuki Warriors(c) **1/2
Baron Corbin v.s Elias *3/4
Women's Title Match: Becky Lynch(c) v.s Shayna Bazler **
IC Title Match: Sami Zayn(c) v.s Daniel Bryan *1/2
SD Tag Team Titles Match: Kofi Kingston v.s Jimmy Uso v.s John Morrison(c) ***1/2
Half No DQ Match: Kevin Owens v.s Seth Rollins ****
Universal Title Match: Braun Strowman v.s Goldberg(c) *
Boneyard Match: A.J. Styles v.s The Undertaker

I can't give the Boneyard match a proper ratin' so all I will say is WWE should do more of this but it shouldn't headline a Mania. The personalities really made it sumthin' worth watchin'. I might get hate for this but eh, some feuds deserve routes like this.

If ya think I underrated or overrated anythin' call me out, you know how it is. The ladder match impressed me and made what to see more ladder matches without obnoxious crowds poppin' for sloppy spots. I think I may have overrated personally too but fuck it, it had a great finish. Owens/Rollins was booked pretty much perfectly. I ain't changin' that ratin'. I know I said I wasn't gonna rate anymore open arena matches but this is this fuckin' Wrestlemania so I had to. Deal with it.

Overall, I enjoyed the fuck out of the show and am still super happy that WWE continued with it. I'm sure the LD was a lot more negative.