I can't really say because the outcome of a match really depends on the feud leading into it. You can't just say "Who would win in a match between this guy and that guy?"
Sure in MMA or boxing you can ask that question because it is legit skills, there are no other factors playing into it.
In a sport like professional wrestling, a question like "who would win?" is irrelevant.
Even though both are true athletes, the only way I can literally answer that question is if the match was real, and that would never happen.