"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Poyser]

I don’t mind lethal’s entrance at all

1000x better than the running commentary I look for when he’s scum lol

 

[Ace Marvel]

Okay, I’m with you, but you’re agreeing that whilst not numerically ensured, it is possible for a smaller number of mafia players to influence the wider town base?

100% but I want to be optimistic, we can avoid situations like those.

 

[Poyser]

I caught your soft so idk why I'd unvote now

Do you think he’s scum?

 

[Smart Marx]

Ok but do you agree with the assessment that we should be picking jeff’s target or do you agree with lethal that we shouldn’t because “scum might be leading consensus”? Seen a lot of arguing the semantics without an actual opinion here

Oh for sure we sure pick the target. Just make sure there’s plenty of voices heard first.

You can’t let suspected pick it solely.

Maybe we could give a pool, but that wouldn’t be necessary without a way for scum to stop it.

 

[Ace Marvel]

POYSER is lock town for me btw.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Ok but do you agree with the assessment that we should be picking jeff’s target or do you agree with lethal that we shouldn’t because “scum might be leading consensus”? Seen a lot of arguing the semantics without an actual opinion here

I say this with the outmost respect, but I will be shooting whomever I see fit. Feedback is welcome but I ain't blind following anyone on day when no one is confirmed. Obviously will be making reads and the likes but I just want to be clear i wont be zombying and giving no thought on it, thats bad a.f for town and wont help you guys get a read on me whatsoever

 

[Mandalorian]

100% but I want to be optimistic, we can avoid situations like those.

We’re on the same page on that front then.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Oh for sure we sure pick the target. Just make sure there’s plenty of voices heard first.

You can’t let suspected pick it solely.

Maybe we could give a pool, but that wouldn’t be necessary without a way for scum to stop it.

How i do it

Everyone gives 3 targets

we count the targets and the 3 the get more votes move to the next round.

The those 3 are voted and the one that gets more votes dies.

not real votes though, thread talking votes.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I say this with the outmost respect, but I will be shooting whomever I see fit. Feedback is welcome but I ain't blind following anyone on day when no one is confirmed. Obviously will be making reads and the likes but I just want to be clear i wont be zombying and giving no thought on it, thats bad a.f for town and wont help you guys get a read on me whatsoever

then you are walking on eggshells and need to die. sorry.

 

[Comrade Khan]

or we just keep hunting and I'll shoot whoever looks sketchy. or ill just shoot tpein because he's a bitch

 

[Comrade Khan]

then you are walking on eggshells and need to die. sorry.

that's not really how mafia works on day1 for me, sorry as well. you don't get to magically choose who I shoot without being town read yourself. if you want to vote me on my play, by all means do so, but I don't take orders.

 

[Smart Marx]

that's not really how mafia works on day1 for me, sorry as well. you don't get to magically choose who I shoot without being town read yourself. if you want to vote me on my play, by all means do so, but I don't take orders.

What if everyone gives their pool of three and the people that are town read the most have a higher value placed on their opinions and we go from there?

 

[Poyser]

Why is newbie behavior , I spect those kind of posts. tbh. not reading town or mafia, but i don't think is bad, I think is normal.

There’s no evidence of real thoughts there, which is why I’m asking him to quote the posts and elaborate a little. Pretty easy to just say oh yeah I was sus of a few people but then people said this is just how they play so idk man

i like people to be specific

 

[Comrade Khan]

I mean no offence btw, I can understand talking stuff out, but if you're thinking of using me as a mindless pawn, I'm not going to simply follow nor will I beg for my life

 

[Comrade Khan]

What if everyone gives their pool of three and the people that are town read the most have a higher value placed on their opinions and we go from there?

that sounds reasonable