"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Lethal]

How would you describe a typical scum Poyser day 1?

Non-confrontational, seeking ways to distance himself from associates, trying to distance himself from anything that can be stuck his way

 

[Smart Marx]

Holy fuck this is a lot of meta commentary. What is your experience in Mafia?

7 or so years.

 

[Sister Abigail]

7 or so years.

Have we played together before? Do I know you under a different username?

 

[Tweet]

So unvote lol

I caught your soft so idk why I'd unvote now

 

[Sister Abigail]

Also I feel as though there are now enough posts for players to start sleuthing. I hate all this player meta talk, or what Town or Wolf should do, so early in the game. It seems like non-contributing drivel.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I think in a game of mafia whether you’re town or scum there needs to be a clear understanding between any two parties in an interaction of what was actually being said if we want to properly read the situation only scum would want to obfuscate what was being said.

Not true, at least for me. Giving people the space to think they are save when in reality every micro interaction is being analyze, is the way to go.

Not forcing a consensus over the target lets people hide and let the kill happen without being accountable for it. Regardless of who is leading it. You can solve more people this way.

So there was no misunderstanding. everyone should give a target and reach consensus.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I caught your soft so idk why I'd unvote now

Cuz im town, dumbass

 

[Smart Marx]

Have we played together before? Do I know you under a different username?

I believe so. I could have been Cicada at the time.

I change my name a lot.

 

[Ace Marvel]

Why didn't you like it? Jeff loves the early drama so I thought he'd pick up me calling him a LOCK Wolf without me having to mention him.

Because it screams you a reading RD for being active, not because you actually have a read, if I'm not active do I get a free pass? No.

 

[Poyser]

Im dayvig dumb dumbs

Hang on, why are you doing this off like one vote lol

 

[Mandalorian]

@Captain Holt

Am I still playing reserved? Why did you think that initially when I was called aggressive as well?

I’m pretty sure it was me he called reserved. Will let Sayer confirm that himself though.

 

[Smart Marx]

Not true, at least for me. Giving people the space to think they are save when in reality every micro interaction is being analyze, is the way to go.

Not forcing a consensus over the target lets people hide and let the kill happen without being accountable for it. Regardless of who is leading it. You can solve more people this way.

So there was no misunderstanding. everyone should give a target and reach consensus.

The misunderstanding comes from you saying scum could be leading the consensus because they don’t have a majority. That wasn’t accurate or what he was saying.

As for the rest of your post, I was commenting on your strategy. I believe on forcing and holding back depending on the particulars of the situation.

 

[Poyser]

Initial reaction is he might be scum tbh

barry LOVES giving scum team extra kills in his games. Was literally just laughing with Odo about that in discord lol

 

[Smart Marx]

Also I feel as though there are now enough posts for players to start sleuthing. I hate all this player meta talk, or what Town or Wolf should do, so early in the game. It seems like non-contributing drivel.

I think not factoring in meta is a mistake. Some players act completely different than others do in the exact same scenarios. As far sleuthing goes, I think it’s started. Dive in.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Because it screams you a reading RD for being active, not because you actually have a read, if I'm not active do I get a free pass? No.

I've already explained this to RD before, so it seems like you missed my post with that. You should go find it. I did not sus RD for being active.