"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Doddsy]

Do you remember who specifically pointed it out so I can iso a bit?

Check my early posts I'm like 99% sure I quoted them

 

[RDK]

That'd maybe make sense if I was an idiot.

You've played with me enough to know that isn't something I'd do, you're completely talking out your ass

I think not thinking he was scum by the end of day 2 does make you an idiot.

But he did flip town

 

[T-Pein™]

The slip wasn't planned it's a dumb theory

So scum can actually do fake slips and town clear as many people as they want and yall just gonna believe it?
Like I said.
This is a legitimate strat and have seen it be done multiple times.
Imagine believing scum?
Yall gonna look silly if it was a play.

 

[John McHenry]

So curious question if I edit a post in here, it doesn't show as edited?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

The slip obviously wasn't planned lol

yeah I thought that was obvious by the fact I immediately quoted it and the answer was "well fuck "

 

[Canadian Dragon]

So scum can actually do fake slips and town clear as many people as they want and yall just gonna believe it?
Like I said.
This is a legitimate strat and have seen it be done multiple times.
Imagine believing scum?
Yall gonna look silly if it was a play.

name them, all the times youve seen it, right now with links to the games

 

[Canadian Dragon]

@Doddsy do you think RDK is scum trying to dirty you or do you think he is town and reading you improperly? please include the whys

 

[RDK]

I like Magic's entrance as his thoughts mainly align with mine.



All seem defensive here and somewhat panicked. So not too good a look


Not a fan of this either, doesn't really address the general suspicion of him but just tries to steer it as a Magic being lazy, I expect town Jeff to take that more head on


This is also a big red flag for me too. Smark vote for starters is an easy one to sort of follow along with here without actually pushing a new point. I would have expected town Jeff to try and get more out of Magic here rather than divert over on to Smark.

The reasoning post is also preemptively defensive which seems more in line with the avoidance sort of play style I'm seeing already here. Not a fan

Not at me but I'm going to take the chance to say I have liked Holt so far. No experience with obviously but seems rational and calm without shying away which I do like. Below posts from Wang and Baldrick who are familiar also say that does fit with town meta.

Ok found it here.

I dont believe for a second you are using Wang to help your read on someone, Baldrick I can believe more, enough to maintain a town read on him given the case presented though? IDK, maybe you're just smarter than everyone else Doddsy

 

[Poyser]

Ok found it here.

I dont believe for a second you are using Wang to help your read on someone, Baldrick I can believe more, enough to maintain a town read on him given the case presented though? IDK, maybe you're just smarter than everyone else Doddsy

huh why is baldrick easy to believe he'd use but not wang?

 

[Lethal]

Come on mate, that's a semantics reply to a very valid question I've asked you. Try again but answer it properly this time

I'm not sure how else I can answer it?

 

[Poyser]

I'm not sure how else I can answer it?

So your answer is you abandoned your play because jeff asked you for your result? lol ok

what was your original intention?

 

[T-Pein™]

I've never seen a planned scum slip in my life

It happens.
This is a role from our "members" mafia.
If town is about to lynch the godfather a useless player dies for them.
Maybe even gives them or another some town cred.

Wanna know who I think gets town cred from this slip?
Red Dragon.
For quoting it and pointing it out.
And of course the other 2 that got named.
Point is.
Do not give town cred based on scum actions .
If any of those are mafia they auto win.
Scrutinize them still.

 

[RDK]

huh why is baldrick easy to believe he'd use but not wang?

Who would you be more susceptible to listening to, Wang or someone you haven't played with before that might have a reasonable skill level? No offense

 

[Lethal]

I tagged Sister asking to talk. Jeff asked for results. I gave them.

ngl I'm pretty fucked off with the flow of this game atm. Forced into a claim cos I didn't want Jeff 1 to die, then getting no results for 2 nights with my usage. Been fun.

 

[Doddsy]

So scum can actually do fake slips and town clear as many people as they want and yall just gonna believe it?
Like I said.
This is a legitimate strat and have seen it be done multiple times.
Imagine believing scum?
Yall gonna look silly if it was a play.

I mean I'm willing to take the chance

@Doddsy do you think RDK is scum trying to dirty you or do you think he is town and reading you improperly? please include the whys

I think he's trying to dirty me, check his initial post pre Holt's flip. He had it set regardless of the result

Ok found it here.

I dont believe for a second you are using Wang to help your read on someone, Baldrick I can believe more, enough to maintain a town read on him given the case presented though? IDK, maybe you're just smarter than everyone else Doddsy

What's with the random shot on Wang? 2 people sticking him to the same meta is pretty solid evidence.

And I am smarter than everyone else