^^^Hogan??!! Yah right. He's way behind Rocky and Rock doesn't list. Seriously, how many memorable Hogan promos do you really remember? They were all the same thing. Nothing stand out about them. There's a reason Roddy's movies did better than Hogan's.
Flair is great but he'd be hard pressed to be better than Foley, HBK, Jake Roberts, Dusty, Roddy Piper and Raven.
Being great on the stic goes way beyond having the charisma to get the fans rallying behind you with catchphrases.
Enzo Malenko, the only worthy contender to Flair's supremacy on your list is HBK. And I said from the outset to pick one American contender and go with him. Pick the one on your list you think is strongest and let's have it out. Cena Mark names too guys, one of whom was basically a cartoon character and claims victory, I agree that HBK could have been as great as Flair, but he missed about 5 years with back problems. Flair suffered a BROKEN back when he was in his early twenties and returned to action less than a year later, rising to stardom almost immediately.
Sean Michaels, on p22 0f the April 2004 edition of Raw Magazine is quoted accordingly:
"Ric Flair's the wrestler that's influenced me more than anyone else. He was a villain in the the ring, but he was still so cool with the machismo, the wheeling and dealing. He always had the best clothes, the best women, the jewellry and the belts. Even from a performance standpoint, he was always the best part of the show. I always tried to pattern my persona and my wrestling style after him for sure. I always felt I wanted to be the 90s version of Ric Flair. I was actually joking with him a while back about how I made a career out of stealing a ton of his stuff and telling everybody it was mine."
So there you have the strongest contender from your list lauding Flair with superlatives.
And as for The Rated R CM Star, he can just wait, watch and learn.