Edge - C.M Punk - Which return did you enjoy more?

[TeaDrinkingLimey]

So I’ve just watched Punk’s return for about the 5th time.
Goosebumps every time.

I’ve now just watched Edge’s return at the Royal Rumble last year for about the 100th time, still goosebumps.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Edge return was awesome but it's comparing a firecracker to an atom bomb. Cm punk all day , that was a once In a decade pop

 

[Dale]

While they're both returns, I think given the nature of each return it's hard to compare them directly. One chose to return from the wilderness, one came back from a forced retirement due to injury.

 

[CakeWalker]

Matt and Jeff at Wrestlemania - was way better than both. Case closed.

 

[Chris]

Yeah actually is kinda hard to compare bc Edge also returned in a match and we saw how good of ring shape he was instantly which was more of a concern in his case too, so he shut all the doubters down instantly. Punk's for a bigger reaction for sure tho

 

[TeaDrinkingLimey]

While they're both returns, I think given the nature of each return it's hard to compare them directly. One chose to return from the wilderness, one came back from a forced retirement due to injury.

For me, I would slightly lean towards Edge.
Mostly because I didn’t think I’d ever see him compete in a wrestling ring again. It was also a genuine surprise and I nearly shit my pants when his music hit.

 

[CakeWalker]

If Edge had returned in Canada - I don't think it would even be up for discussion.

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Depends what you mean better.

I marked more on the Edge one, but the dude is my second favorite of all time, and where I heard reports he was coming back, I believed them way way less than Punk so I went batshit when his music hit.

But in the grand scheme of things, I am giving it to Punk off the fact where he could have came back, he didn’t, people chanted his name for years, yeah mainly Chicago, but he would get them other places for a bit. They sold out a basketball stadium on a RUMOR, that’s wild. So slightly Punk edges out Edge.

 

[TeaDrinkingLimey]

Depends what you mean better.

I marked more on the Edge one, but the dude is my second favorite of all time, and where I heard reports he was coming back, I believed them way way less than Punk so I went batshit when his music hit.

But in the grand scheme of things, I am giving it to Punk off the fact where he could have came back, he didn’t, people chanted his name for years, yeah mainly Chicago, but he would get them other places for a bit. They sold out a basketball stadium on a RUMOR, that’s wild. So slightly Punk edges out Edge.

Maybe I should rephrase?

“Which return did you enjoy more?”

 

[CakeWalker]

Maybe I should rephrase?

“Which return did you enjoy more?”

Will Ospreay

 

[Chris]

Will Ospreay

Which poll option is he, I don't see it?

 

[CakeWalker]

You need Nord VPN I think

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Maybe I should rephrase?

“Which return did you enjoy more?”

I have to see the long run play out because the follow up could change my mind.

 

[TeaDrinkingLimey]

I have to see the long run play out because the follow up could change my mind.

AEW surely can’t fuck this up?

If there is as much creative freedom as we’re led to believe, it surely can’t be fucked up?

 

[Hidden Blaze]

AEW surely can’t fuck this up?

If there is as much creative freedom as we’re led to believe, it surely can’t be fucked up?

Anything can be fucked up, but chances are they won’t. I’ll say as of now it’s still Punk for me. But I’ll get back to you in a month or two.