Dungeon & Dragons Mafia - Game Thread [GAME OVER]

[Sister Abigail]

Like the only way I really see Jeff being town here is if we only have a single wolf remaining?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Keep telling you you're not looking at things with an open mind Abi

This boy ain't scum

 

[Sister Abigail]

Ninja'd.

It makes me feel confused.

If Wang or Mando are wolves, it's an easy hammer. Unless it's not LYLO and we only have two wolves (unlikely) and they're afraid to hammer.

If Jeff is wolf, one is a partner and the other is just town reading him.

If all three are town, that means you and Tpein are wolves and that's a tough sell.

It's definitely an interesting scenario.

Also if Tpein is not town, how does wolves have an extra kill in this setup? Is that what the BP and doc were for?

Did Tpein lie about the Blaze kill? That means that kill was done by someone else which suggest a third party.

 

[Ultra]

I mean at this point I feel like I've been hoodwinked and 2/3 of my poe is trash. and ill ask you the same, why arent they hammering me when my death seems inevitable. why are they purposefully making themselves look bad if im scum? once is weird twice might mean its you and your boys voting are not only wrong, some of you may be scum!

for real though I dont really have another explanation, and from your pov, they both cant be scum if im scum because the game would be over wouldnt it

My assumption would be that you would get bussed here, but that is weaker than my assumption that if you were town wolves would absolutely hammer and then win the game.

Ninja'd.

It makes me feel confused.

If Wang or Mando are wolves, it's an easy hammer. Unless it's not LYLO and we only have two wolves (unlikely) and they're afraid to hammer.

If Jeff is wolf, one is a partner and the other is just town reading him.

If all three are town, that means you and Tpein are wolves and that's a tough sell.

It's definitely an interesting scenario.

Well as things currently stand, if they don't vote, Jeff doesn't go over. If one is town and hard pocketed they could just be leaning into that instead of going for a bus and picking up the pieces later. Maybe Jeff isn't really expendable.

In any case, we might have to compromise here

 

[Sister Abigail]

Keep telling you you're not looking at things with an open mind Abi

This boy ain't scum

Jeff, help me help you then. Because so many scenarios do not make sense in my head.

I assume we have two wolves left because Barry's flip literally said 'your teammates are'.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

@Ultra counter point, what if scum can't hammer b3cause they already on the wagon

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Jeff, help me help you then. Because so many scenarios do not make sense in my head.

I assume we have two wolves left because Barry's flip literally said 'your teammates are'.

I think you're on the right track with tpein tbh. I cant explain scum not hammering other than they already on wagon. Which means u pain or ultra, or were dealing with 1s 13p which would b pein? I guess Mando too

 

[Ultra]

@Ultra counter point, what if scum can't hammer b3cause they already on the wagon

Then it's exactly X and T-Pein. That's basically the only alternative explanation. Find it less likely though

 

[Sister Abigail]

My assumption would be that you would get bussed here, but that is weaker than my assumption that if you were town wolves would absolutely hammer and then win the game.



Well as things currently stand, if they don't vote, Jeff doesn't go over. If one is town and hard pocketed they could just be leaning into that instead of going for a bus and picking up the pieces later. Maybe Jeff isn't really expendable.

In any case, we might have to compromise here

It's just hard to see a world where Jeff isn't wolf here.

If Jeff is town, I'd say Wang and Mando are the team, but neither are hammering.

If Jeff is town, and only one of Wang and Mando are wolf, that means he has a partner between you and Tpein.

If Tpein is wolf, he lied about being the vig and that Blaze kill still lingers; do wolves have an extra kill?

If Tpein is town, you are wolf.

 

[Sister Abigail]

I think you're on the right track with tpein tbh. I cant explain scum not hammering other than they already on wagon. Which means u pain or ultra, or were dealing with 1s 13p which would b pein? I guess Mando too

Why does wolves have an extra kill in this game then if Tpein is wolf?

We also know there are two wolves because Barry's PM said teammates.

 

[Sister Abigail]

DAY ONE FLIP

Everyone worth a dragon [golden coin] in the City of Splendour, has been called to the 'Hall of Heretics' to pass their judgement following the brutal murder of Grog. Votes had been cast and the final ballot is as shown below:

DAY ONE - FINAL COUNT

Jeff Valley Driver [1] - Lethal
Grim [7] - Ultra, Jeff Valley Driver, Sky, T-Pein, Blaze, Pendex, Mandalorian
Pendex [1] - Sister Abigail

A judgement has been reached, and the executioner has been called and Grim has been executed!

GRIM

You are Manshoon [Mafia Alignment]

Role: Mafia Godfather & Stalker

Your team-mates are REDACTED. You may talk to them during night phases only. You will be unable to contact them until Night One - when a chat will be created.

You have the following active ability:
Each Night, you may target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, you will learn that player's role (but not their alignment).

You have the following passive ability:
If investigated by a Cop, you will appear innocent on all investigations.

As a member of the mafia you also have a factional night kill - that you must decide as a group who you wish to target.

You win if at least one mafia member is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).

- False Identity -
Khelben "Blackstaff" Arunsun

Role: Jester

Twilight will end in a couple of minutes.
​

Definitely dealing with more than one remaining wolf.

 

[Ultra]

It's just hard to see a world where Jeff isn't wolf here.

If Jeff is town, I'd say Wang and Mando are the team, but neither are hammering.

If Jeff is town, and only one of Wang and Mando are wolf, that means he has a partner between you and Tpein.

If Tpein is wolf, he lied about being the vig and that Blaze kill still lingers; do wolves have an extra kill?

If Tpein is town, you are wolf.

Your assessment here is correct

Caviet here being that regardless of alignment I'm not sure how much attention Mando/Wang have actually been paying, so that could undermine some assumption here. But they'd have to be pretty daft to have it dictated to them that he's at -1 and not hammer, so I'm thinking this is soft confirmation he's a wolf

 

[Sister Abigail]

Hmmmmmmm.

Does John being one shot BP counter wolf Tpein having an extra kill?

 

[Sister Abigail]

Your assessment here is correct

Caviet here being that regardless of alignment I'm not sure how much attention Mando/Wang have actually been paying, so that could undermine some assumption here. But they'd have to be pretty daft to have it dictated to them that he's at -1 and not hammer, so I'm thinking this is soft confirmation he's a wolf

Lethal was also L-1 and did not get hammered. wtf are wolves doing this game?

 

[Sister Abigail]

Lethal was also L-1 and did not get hammered. wtf are wolves doing this game?

Was this D2 or D3? I think D2.