Doctor Who Mafia - Game Thread

[Marty McFourth]

I'm thinking that we should push CP tomorrow. His posts are all wallpapery, he's dipped in and out which he tends to do more as scum. As town he's more likely to dip in with multiquotes on wagons and make his time here count. I haven't got that vibe from him tbh.

It's between you, CP and Christopher for me.

Did you get the chance to look back at Day 1 wagons after the executioner thing?

I agree that CP has felt non-existent aside from his Poyser suspicion. Poyser isn't confirmed town by any stretch, he's certainly a capable player as scum. I really don't think he'd execute Lethal either, I know WIFOM and all that. I just find it highly unlikely with his early play on TP and overall play that'd it be scum Poyser.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Yeah mitch definitely needs to post more

Why is Poyser town he seems kinda WEASELY to me

These posts are interesting to me because I think it was actually Poyser who brought attention to Mitch first, so it seems like CP is sort of agreeing with him there. Then he calls Poyser weasely later. I suppose it could be just CP trolling/joking around considering he's not posted much himself.

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

These posts are interesting to me because I think it was actually Poyser who brought attention to Mitch first, so it seems like CP is sort of agreeing with him there. Then he calls Poyser weasely later. I suppose it could be just CP trolling/joking around considering he's not posted much himself.

I alluded to this earlier but I think it was more of a joke at his own post count


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Big Man]

It's between you, CP and Christopher for me.

Did you get the chance to look back at Day 1 wagons after the executioner thing?

I agree that CP has felt non-existent aside from his Poyser suspicion. Poyser isn't confirmed town by any stretch, he's certainly a capable player as scum. I really don't think he'd execute Lethal either, I know WIFOM and all that. I just find it highly unlikely with his early play on TP and overall play that'd it be scum Poyser.

Flay was pressuring him after < 25 posts had been made into the game, so there wasn't much value to extract from that.

 

[Doddsy]

I'm not opposed to CP, he hasn't really said anything at all so far as far as I've noticed.

 

[Doddsy]

I've not minded Poyser so far

 

[Doddsy]

Yes I am indeed splitting up these posts to pad my post count

 

[Marty McFourth]

Yes I am indeed splitting up these posts to pad my post count

Convenient timing, Mr. Doddsy

What do you think to Chris? He's a got a bit of heat on him and he's gone quiet

 

[Marty McFourth]

I alluded to this earlier but I think it was more of a joke at his own post count


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The problem with CP is it's hard to tell when he's serious or joking around

 

[Wangman Page]

If he claimed after he was half majority questions would be raised about why the execute wasn't used on him. Him claiming from one vote completely negates that point, and you don't generally claim off one vote, especially with a power role like vig.

Seems to me like he could have done it to avoid execute spec later. Could be coincidence too but

That's probably a fair point

Mitch as scum wouldn't mention it at all and let the day go with everyone just playing a guessing game. From all the games I have played with him. Mitch tries to be upfront with roles like what he has if he has done something.


"If you have a problem, if no one else can help, and if you can find them....maybe you can hire The Tap A-Team

 

[Doddsy]

Convenient timing, Mr. Doddsy

What do you think to Chris? He's a got a bit of heat on him and he's gone quiet

I've honestly barely noticed any of his posts so far. Quick squiz doesn't look like there's much of note

 

[Doddsy]

Mitch as scum wouldn't mention it at all and let the day go with everyone just playing a guessing game. From all the games I have played with him. Mitch tries to be upfront with roles like what he has if he has done something.


"If you have a problem, if no one else can help, and if you can find them....maybe you can hire The Tap A-Team

Certainly possible, I'm not looking at this like a slam dunk.

By wouldn't mention it at all you mean he wouldn't acknowledge the votes on him?

 

[Wangman Page]

Certainly possible, I'm not looking at this like a slam dunk.

By wouldn't mention it at all you mean he wouldn't acknowledge the votes on him?

Not about the votes to me when I read that whole interaction at that time it was hey I killed Flay when he opened up the thread.


As scum he wouldn't have said that until much later with more votes on him not one.


"If you have a problem, if no one else can help, and if you can find them....maybe you can hire The Tap A-Team

 

[PHEN0M]

This. It mostly stood out because I’m not sure I ever remember phenom having these kinds of concerns before or using this kind of reasoning not to wagon somebody? Of course, if he’d have known lethal was about to be executed he probably wouldn’t wanna be on the wagon if he could help it. It’s not bad reasoning in and of itself because it probably would be a while until lethal showed up, but like I said I’m not sure I’ve ever seen phenom in particular show concern for that kind of thing

I was waiting to see if anyone tried to paint me in a bad light for that. It’s complete coincidence but i knew I’d catch heat from it at some point.

 

[PHEN0M]