Doctor Who Mafia - Game Thread

[Marty McFourth]

I’m going to flip a switch starting day 3, i know if i start going to work during night I’ll end up dead.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I think CP is kinda just talking shit at this juncture lol

Talking shit as in you think it's town CP or what?

 

[Poyser]

That is the first point from Doddsy I have really liked in this game, I'm really torn on Mitch. If we're talking play, I still am not a fan. However his claim does line up with Flay being dead. Flay shot Magic, Mitch shot Flay and then Chevy got janitored by Mafia, right? It would have looked more suspect to me if Mitch never suspected Flay but took credit for the kill.

This seems the most likely scenario yeah. And that's just it, it lines up but it also perfectly lines up with chevy shooting flay too so it's kinda dismissable. Im still stuck on the fact that mitch randomly concluded flay was bussing TP which I really just dont think makes sense to think of somebody that you've not played with much lol

 

[Big Man]

I hate janitors tbh, unless Mitch can prove another shot it's really a crapshoot as to whether he's telling the truth or not

He's not removed out of my POE, only for the time being

He claimed the kill immediately into day, so I doubt he’d be lying. I don’t think he fakes it himself, so it requires the scum team to be super on the ball and provide that usage right off the bat.

personally, I wouldn’t select Mitch to claim this kinda role since the role has a shelf life, so I’d want someone who could do as much damage with it as possible. Like leading mislynches etc so I wouldn’t pick Mitch, further leading me into thinking hes legitimate

 

[Lethal]

Thanks for the game, Ace

 

[Poyser]

Talking shit as in you think it's town CP or what?

Im not entirely sure tbh, but it seems all he really wants to do atm is keep shading me, I haven't really seen him do anything else. And I think the point about waiting for lethal before pushing him is a load of fucking shite like if I think I can read lethal really easily then why wouldn't I push him, especially when he's offered the grand sum of fuck all so far when he usually gets pretty involved in the game when he was around. Im not sure I really see that point of view coming from a townie trying to figure the game out because it doesnt make any sense lol

 

[Marty McFourth]

Maybe they executed lethal because they were worried the wagon might go to a scum if lethal had a good claim? Although I think it was only you offering up different alternatives but it would probably point to big man or tweet yeah

big man has definitely been underwhelming so far, he’s usually not very active but I’m used to him coming in and making good points when he is around as opposed to just making excuses lol

I could buy that. There's a lot of people that likely won't get pushed at present so it really only leaves limited options

My only gripe with that logic is that it really was just speculation on their part considering their rolecopper already flipped. Lethal didn't look great, so you could have took that gamble of him being lynched

 

[Marty McFourth]

Im not entirely sure tbh, but it seems all he really wants to do atm is keep shading me, I haven't really seen him do anything else. And I think the point about waiting for lethal before pushing him is a load of fucking shite like if I think I can read lethal really easily then why wouldn't I push him, especially when he's offered the grand sum of fuck all so far when he usually gets pretty involved in the game when he was around. Im not sure I really see that point of view coming from a townie trying to figure the game out because it doesnt make any sense lol

He was willing to sheep Magic on Flay without reading, that's all else I can remember from his play this game lol

I thought that Lethal line was shady as well. It's not like you see an execute everyday either, no reason not to push on him based on play, I don't even remember seeing that role before.

 

[Marty McFourth]

He claimed the kill immediately into day, so I doubt he’d be lying. I don’t think he fakes it himself, so it requires the scum team to be super on the ball and provide that usage right off the bat.

personally, I wouldn’t select Mitch to claim this kinda role since the role has a shelf life, so I’d want someone who could do as much damage with it as possible. Like leading mislynches etc so I wouldn’t pick Mitch, further leading me into thinking hes legitimate

Claiming the kill immediately would have looked better if the execute didn't go down, as it makes it look like he was avoiding reaching the threshold

I do agree that a lot of this seems to be based on Mitch making the moves quickly on his own as scum, that's why I lean towards it being legitimate.

 

[Alco]

I mean with how sus Chevy was of Flay it's entirely possible he shot him too tbh. But I agree it's too much into speculation for the moment to make a solid conclusion on it.

TFW is like my only firm town read for the moment. I'm worried... scared.

 

[Alco]

He claimed the kill immediately into day, so I doubt he’d be lying. I don’t think he fakes it himself, so it requires the scum team to be super on the ball and provide that usage right off the bat.

personally, I wouldn’t select Mitch to claim this kinda role since the role has a shelf life, so I’d want someone who could do as much damage with it as possible. Like leading mislynches etc so I wouldn’t pick Mitch, further leading me into thinking hes legitimate

Unless Mitch is the only one with an unclaimable role on the scum team

But yea, it could go either way. I just think it's highly convenient.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Not that I’m giving him a town read for it, but he does lurk a lot as town too I think. I don’t think it’s AI for him. I don’t think his contributions have been great though tbh

I feel like Chris hasn't really had a stance since the TP vote on Day 1. That and his lurking and not many contributions isn't looking great for him. He could definitely be riding off the bit of credit he got for voting TP

Do you still have Phen0m as Town? I think he's in the same pool as Alco and Chris that they done a couple of things but could easily be blending in. Honestly think Alco has looked the best out of them, but idk

 

[Marty McFourth]

I mean with how sus Chevy was of Flay it's entirely possible he shot him too tbh. But I agree it's too much into speculation for the moment to make a solid conclusion on it.

TFW is like my only firm town read for the moment. I'm worried... scared.

You should have Blaine in there too as firm imo, he's double voter with an executioner confirmed. Unless Ace made the scum team super powerful, I don't buy him being on their team. Obviously you can make your own observations on that though, as it is set-up spec. Blaine has at least put some effort in compared to his scum game as well, not a lot but enough to distinguish them

 

[Alco]

Every time I read Chris I always give the same arguments as to why he could be scum and it's like a 50/50 chance if he's actually scum or not

 

[Alco]

You should have Blaine in there too as firm imo, he's double voter with an executioner confirmed. Unless Ace made the scum team super powerful, I don't buy him being on their team. Obviously you can make your own observations on that though, as it is set-up spec. Blaine has at least put some effort in compared to his scum game as well, not a lot but enough to distinguish them

Eh yea you're probably right.