Doctor Who Mafia - Game Thread

[Showtime]

You were so anxious to see the flip and yet the only thing you mention later is Magic/Flay. What gives?

This is a good point

 

[Evans]

I read through all of Day 1 and decided "fuck it, I'm not even gonna bother gleaning anything from it." T-Pein was such a distraction and an annoyance that I'm not re-reading it. I'm playing for the present, and I really don't give a shit if people sus me or not.

I think Magic's read on Flay is just completely wrong, and the idea that scum would just lynch their godfather so willingly, despite the fact he was being lynched for being annoying. I don't think anyone even actually read him scum, just annoying and needed to go.

Wasn’t he a rolecop

 

[Showtime]

Magic isn't gonna like this but right now I'm feeling like him and Flay is town/town. That is the impression I got reading through their pages of interactions. Flay can't really defend himself against an accusation he bussed because what is there to say really? "I didn't bus" is all you can really do

I'm happy to be wrong on this one, it wouldn't be the first time.

Unless some overwhelming evidence comes about that is damning I wouldn't be comfortable lynching Flay in this game

Tfw I don't like this because losing to a day 1 buss is about as garbage as it gets. Flay as town has no reason to be kept alive the whole game.


The perc game poyser is talking about with the scum guy is the one I caught and pushed on day 1 while no one listened to me. He died day 3 after a bunch of townie deaths. I've played this game a long time. There was nothing natural about flays push

 

[Big Man]

I think Flay is probably town as I don't really see him making such an aggressive bus early doors. I know Magic will try and dismiss my points on him like he did in sacking mafia, but Flay seems the sort of player to want everyone to get through the game. I think he usually brags about the dashing_man game a few years back still

 

[Showtime]

There is no logical reason you can say it was a bus

It's just pure agenda rather than actual play at this point

Look at this defense and anyone tell me when I've ever tried lynching someone for agenda reasons instead of my win condition. His entire defense has been shit too. Agenda for what?

 

[Tweet]

even when he’s already on his way out of the game by the time you’d made your first posts?

Yeah, it's not like getting on the wagon for obviously bad reasons is gonna get me town reads even if TP flips scum.

 

[Showtime]

I think Flay is probably town as I don't really see him making such an aggressive bus early doors. I know Magic will try and dismiss my points on him like he did in sacking mafia, but Flay seems the sort of player to want everyone to get through the game. I think he usually brags about the dashing_man game a few years back still

Flay was scum in sacking mafia and you helped lynched him thinking he was town

 

[Poyser]

Its just because you're jealous he got more votes than you to go the champs imo

 

[Evans]

You remember the circumstances in which I did that right? We had no even night kill so I thought to take advantage of an obvious disadvantage. Of course Juice fucked us with revealing that mechanic in the flip but you have to admit it was a viable idea.

Where was the disadvantage for scum in regards to T-Pein in the thread? People had difficulty reading him so as a team mate I could have easily let him slip but I made a decent case on him. And people agreed added their own thoughts on him.

Yeah I get the circumstances but I’m not paying attention to them.

I’m saying you’d make risky gambles and plays as scum.

 

[Big Man]

Look at this defense and anyone tell me when I've ever tried lynching someone for agenda reasons instead of my win condition. His entire defense has been shit too. Agenda for what?

Most of what he says is obnoxious dismissible garbage, I think it's more sensible to judge by actions. Although if I recall correctly, he did accuse you of having an agenda against him the last couple of times you bodied him early, so I suppose it's fairly touch and go

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Wasn’t he a rolecop

Yes, so logically, why would Flay bus the fucking role cop that early when he wasn't in danger of being lynched?

 

[Chloe B]

The perc game poyser is talking about with the scum guy is the one I caught and pushed on day 1 while no one listened to me. He died day 3 after a bunch of townie deaths. I've played this game a long time. There was nothing natural about flays push

Do you even think when you post

there is no connection between different games with different players, you're using your reputation to make your cases which is trash which leads me to ask

Do you think people will actually listen to you?

 

[Tweet]

I read through all of Day 1 and decided "fuck it, I'm not even gonna bother gleaning anything from it." T-Pein was such a distraction and an annoyance that I'm not re-reading it. I'm playing for the present, and I really don't give a shit if people sus me or not.

I think Magic's read on Flay is just completely wrong, and the idea that scum would just lynch their godfather so willingly, despite the fact he was being lynched for being annoying. I don't think anyone even actually read him scum, just annoying and needed to go.

Relating hard with the first paragraph

 

[Showtime]

1. You got cold feet on the T-Pein wagon
2. Blaine did mention the Doddsy/Barry interaction first and you could have easily ripped it off him

You also got cold feet on it when you tried confirming him.


Tfw is obvious town. I think most would agree with that ya

 

[Evans]

Yes, so logically, why would Flay bus the fucking role cop that early when he wasn't in danger of being lynched?

This has been covered plenty in my posts