Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[Tommy Bedlam]

Shit. Thought I quoted SA's comment about me fence sitting. That's what I'm referring to in that reply.

 

[Sister Abigail]

It was also early in the conversation, and I wasn't comfortable throwing a vote. It was also before I found out more about framing roles. Right now, I lean heavily towards Mcknight being Jeff's visitor on the night of his death.

Why lean heavily? In a game where info has constantly been questioned, why should we trust Switch?

 

[Smart Marx]

Why lean heavily? In a game where info has constantly been questioned, why should we trust Switch?

No other visitor roles have come forward, and why McHenry of all people? You don’t think I’d frame Gip?

I wanted Ekko nailed here, but it is what it is.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Why lean heavily? In a game where info has constantly been questioned, why should we trust Switch?

Because if the SK is still floating around I don't see throwing out fake info on someone who claimed to be a VT as beneficial to the scum side, unless they have some sort of inside info that one more mislynch ends the game.

 

[Smart Marx]

Because if the SK is still floating around I don't see throwing out fake info on someone who claimed to be a VT as beneficial to the scum side, unless they have some sort of inside info that one more mislynch ends the game.

It wouldn’t end the game because the serial killer still alive so they’d still be able to shoot scum at night.

Suicide mission.

 

[Sister Abigail]

I guess I don't see why Smark would fake info now of all times, like I said, getting one mislynch here probably doesn't win scum the game yet

Because Switch knew mass claims were going to happen today. Claiming Watcher as well as having his actions prepared, knowing people would ask him about actions makes sense. I feel Watcher in this setup is weird.

 

[Smart Marx]

Because Switch knew mass claims were going to happen today. Claiming Watcher as well as having his actions prepared, knowing people would ask him about actions makes sense. I feel Watcher in this setup is weird.

And then get shot by the serial killer?

 

[Sister Abigail]

Because if the SK is still floating around I don't see throwing out fake info on someone who claimed to be a VT as beneficial to the scum side, unless they have some sort of inside info that one more mislynch ends the game.

So you're thinking SK would be scared enough of Watcher not to reveal themselves? What if scum already know who SK is and can block/kill them next night?

 

[Sister Abigail]

And then get shot by the serial killer?

^

 

[Sister Abigail]

If scum know who SK is, it's no worries.

 

[John McHenry]

To me this is a fine enough explanation on the 'I think' issue. I feel Switch continuing this argument after feels wrong.

Was it you that thought switch could be sk?

If SK he could kill jeff, blame me he's got a 50/50 shot on me being scum of some sort if he's right I'm scum he walks away clean. If he's wrong he can use the only argument that i as town can make I'm being framed in someway and uses that as his defense. But he eliminates the caroler potentially doing a great deal of good for his scum teammates even if his story of herp derp I was wrong Mc was framed and he's lynched tomorrow.

 

[Smart Marx]

So you're thinking SK would be scared enough of Watcher not to reveal themselves? What if scum already know who SK is and can block/kill them next night?

I guess that’s up to you decide which scenario has more what ifs. There’s been no visiting roles revealed yet and I don’t know what the other players are. Risky gamble.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Was it you that thought switch could be sk?

If SK he could kill jeff, blame me he's got a 50/50 shot on me being scum of some sort if he's right I'm scum he walks away clean. If he's wrong he can use the only argument that i as town can make I'm being framed in someway and uses that as his defense. But he eliminates the caroler potentially doing a great deal of good for his scum teammates even if his story of herp derp I was wrong Mc was framed and he's lynched tomorrow.

I've never suggested Switch could be SK, but I don't think he's Town.

 

[Sister Abigail]

I guess that’s up to you decide which scenario has more what ifs. There’s been no visiting roles revealed yet and I don’t know what the other players are. Risky gamble.

Watcher just feels weird in this game when we know info is kind of fucked this game. Just my gut feeling. I just don't think you're Town.

 

[Smart Marx]

Watcher just feels weird in this game when we know info is kind of fucked this game. Just my gut feeling. I just don't think you're Town.

That’s entirely the point. All these other roles are so funky but watcher is fairly straightforward.