Death Note Mafia - Game Thread

[Evans]

Completely disagree that discussing possible scum characters would draw attention. It might indirectly if that’s all you’re doing and not talking about anything game related but that in itself isn’t an attention drawer, sorry. People do it in some capacity almost every game lol

you were on smark before his claim were you not? I think you’re just shoehorning reasons to read him scum here and I’m not convinced it’s above board or you would at least be lending weight to the fact that he literally helped me kick the banez wagon off back when I first started giving banez suspicion and then again when I asked for votes. That’s a very quick decision to bus the motherfucker because he was instantly saying I was making a good case

Even discussing your own character as scum?

Yes, what triggered actually pushing that direction was the “I didn’t read my PM! Banez was in my flavour”. I’d disagree I’m shoehorning, I’ve had the main reasons and I’ve stuck with them. The whole argument was over a minor point that I was trying to dispute.

Do you think it’s odd how quickly Banez tapped out? It was poor. The thread showed as much with how easily he tapped out. I don’t think if you really consider how easy he gave up that a quick bus is out of the question tbh.

 

[Evans]

re: Smark/Evans

Is it not normal for people to speculate as to whom the scum characters may be? I know I used it as my crutch in Star Wars and Prison Break to appear productive, but it's also decent to have a bank of data to judge claims from

It is normal.

I perceive it to be risky to engage in setup/theme spec about your own character as scum.

 

[Lethal]

Are we to assume you don’t have a daykill then lethal?

I was bullshitting. Trying to rabbit ears him into appearing and having a go. Sorry.

It is normal.

I perceive it to be risky to engage in setup/theme spec about your own character as scum.

 

[Poyser]

Even discussing your own character as scum?

Yes, what triggered actually pushing that direction was the “I didn’t read my PM! Banez was in my flavour”. I’d disagree I’m shoehorning, I’ve had the main reasons and I’ve stuck with them. The whole argument was over a minor point that I was trying to dispute.

Do you think it’s odd how quickly Banez tapped out? It was poor. The thread showed as much with how easily he tapped out. I don’t think if you really consider how easy he gave up that a quick bus is out of the question tbh.

But smark was on him before he tapped out. Would they have not at least tried to make it look better IE banez going at smark or even mentioning him at all if they just decided to bus that quickly?

and no, discussing your own character as scum is irrelevant to the point because nobody knows you’re that character and won’t until you’re dead lol

 

[Poyser]

I think if someone bussed banez from a good position it’s way more likely to be gambit

 

[Poyser]

Eh

vote OMB

let’s just end it and move on

 

[Smart Marx]

My vote should still be there.

 

[Evans]

But smark was on him before he tapped out. Would they have not at least tried to make it look better IE banez going at smark or even mentioning him at all if they just decided to bus that quickly?

and no, discussing your own character as scum is irrelevant to the point because nobody knows you’re that character and won’t until you’re dead lol

I’ll reread the Banez wagon when I wake up later and get back to you.

And then you flip scum and all of the posts you’ve made around the scum team etc now carry more importance as posts from a scum player that could end up exposing your teammates. Ya feel me?

 

[Poyser]

vote banez

easy

huh?

On this debate?

I dont really know. But Poyser is heated enough so he's probably town, scum Poyser wouldn't draw attention to himself like that.

Oh yeah I forgot

more votes on banez plz

Wait, what's Banez done? Unless you're waiting for him to say something and in that case answer this later.

He probably looks for 2 things.

1) me to react.

2) Me to throw a fit.

I was waiting for him but don’t think it’s needed right now. Scum banez is a coward

town banez prides himself on reading everything in the game and having his own thoughts. He wouldn’t just ask for a summary lol. I was going to wait and see if he went back and read himself and posted his own thoughts but he never did, yet he responded to brutus immediately as if he had read the debate. And even then when prodded for his thoughts he provided only a town read on me (the person pushing him) which just screams like he’s trying to placate me. Offered nothing on you, Doddsy, gambit, ace or anybody else

How do you think he'll interpret you answering me and not giving him what he wants?

I had time to read the debate. I wanted to see if anyone bothered giving me an answer but it went for deaf ears.

And by deaf ears i mean mainly you coz you like to post 200+ posts in day one.

Prides himself on reading everything in the game?

You might wanna take a look at my previous game and the past town games here, i haven't really bothered reading them through at all as town.

I used to do that but when people talk down to me like my opinion doesn't matter i stopped doing it coz my efforts were pointless.

If you read it yourself why would you wait for somebody to give you a summary?

I assume responding to me first can also be seen that way. He avoided the confrontation with you first?

Well he did but he tried to avoid it already by just reading me town. I think he’d be offering his own thoughts without waiting to be asked anyways tho

I asked the question after skimming thread, i then saw 2 posts from you and Doddsy both ignoring what i asked so i went and read it, then i replied to Brutus.

Do i have to explain every little thing i do in the between now for you?



I'll find you an example.

Game is too early to give reads and people pass town reads like candy these days. I'm not about that. I gave you a town lean because you are on my case like a squirrel chasing bag of nuts. And you dont do that when you are scum, as scum you always buddy up with me and agree no matter how ridiculous statement i'd be making which is why i think my lean is correct.

On another point, I think banez’ read on me is actually a good one. However, I don’t really believe a town banez who is always naturally wary of me makes it lol. I usually have to catch 3 scum to get a town read from him so I don’t really see him giving one for me being prickly lmao

You realise how contradictory this is don’t you lol

if you had to vote somebody right now who would it be?

This is how I generally feel about you or Odo most games. Can't be too sure until you are, lol.

Usually if I give a town Odo or Poyser a strong town read early, I'm goodguying (that's what you said before I think) you guys.

Biggest problems i've had in past games as town is that i am too wary and i dont take risks on trusting reads and my initial gut feel. I'm gonna try to do that more often now.

I don't necessarily hate the thought process from Poyser on this train.

Is Poyser the only vote on him thus far?

Like I just think smark reacted to this completely naturally

 

[Roy Mustang]

I think if someone bussed banez from a good position it’s way more likely to be gambit

Tbf this. I joined a bit later than poyser and i think Smark did. I'm not sure either are scum tbh. I'd also feel like poyser if it was him would have spoke with banez in the qt

Sent from my SM-A202F using Tapatalk

 

[Poyser]

I’ll reread the Banez wagon when I wake up later and get back to you.

And then you flip scum and all of the posts you’ve made around the scum team etc now carry more importance as posts from a scum player that could end up exposing your teammates. Ya feel me?

Not really because all they’ve got from you is what characters they’re likely to be (and it’s even a jump to suggest you’re being truthful). What use is that?

 

[Evans]

But smark was on him before he tapped out. Would they have not at least tried to make it look better IE banez going at smark or even mentioning him at all if they just decided to bus that quickly?

who has been pushing Haza this game?

I think Banez going at anyone right before his death as he’s about to tap out is glaringly obvious as a distancing attempt, as we’ve seen people pushing Haza because of that.

surely they’d prefer to setup a mislynch than risk distancing getting caught?

 

[Smart Marx]

If Poyser flips scum, I’ll shit a brick.

 

[Poyser]

who has been pushing Haza this game?

I think Banez going at anyone right before his death as he’s about to tap out is glaringly obvious as a distancing attempt, as we’ve seen people pushing Haza because of that.

surely they’d prefer to setup a mislynch than risk distancing getting caught?

Banez started to push haza way before he tapped out tho from memory, he did it when I was the only vote

 

[Evans]

Not really because all they’ve got from you is what characters they’re likely to be (and it’s even a jump to suggest you’re being truthful). What use is that?

What about scum teammates who are also pushing the same spec during the conversation? I mean I dont think you’ll see the risks the same as I do, so it is what it is.

I don’t feel any different about it