Death Note Mafia - Game Thread

[Poyser]

Are you gonna blast OMB or what lethal

 

[Smart Marx]

Personally I don’t think a claim would hurt unless we think he’s a strong town role, but since I probably won’t be on much tomorrow, I’ll leave my vote on omb.

 

[Smart Marx]

Although I think CP’s counter was that it came a lot earlier than I thought it did and I haven’t read back the context

I think that was me because I did actually answer you on that post when you originally asked it and I found it on page 26 before he was even on 5 votes I think.

 

[Lethal]

If you have a day kill then just take out OMB so we can move on and try and get something done. It’s a good kill no matter the flip because even if he’s scum, he’s botched this so hard that we probably aren’t gonna get a lot out of the flip. If he’s town then we are obviously just wasting a day phase on his shite

No but if it’s me trying to start a case and you add a vote on (after I pointed out nothing else is happening) then you obviously know it’s gonna come to needing to claim lol

True. I mean, gun to my head, I doubt Smark sticks his neck out to save Banez

 

[Poyser]

Reads/leans list:

Town - Poyser, Barry, CP, Ace

Scum - OMB, Smark, Haza, Gambit

Nulls for everyone else. Hoping this changes sooner than later.

I kinda have a problem with 3/4 of your scum team being people that were either on banez early or banez was on them early lol. It’s like you’ve not put any thought into it at all

 

[Smart Marx]

I kinda have a problem with 3/4 of your scum team being people that were either on banez early or banez was on them early lol. It’s like you’ve not put any thought into it at all

Tbh that’s my least questionable part. Because if he thinks we bussed nom early at least he’s got us all.

Like we all decided to bus him together.

 

[Poyser]

Also OMB appeared on your scum list but you hadn’t even mentioned his name once, only went further into detail later when I said I think OMB is scum

 

[Poyser]

I also don’t think he mentioned gambit either

 

[Lethal]

If you have a day kill then just take out OMB so we can move on and try and get something done. It’s a good kill no matter the flip because even if he’s scum, he’s botched this so hard that we probably aren’t gonna get a lot out of the flip. If he’s town then we are obviously just wasting a day phase on his shite

No but if it’s me trying to start a case and you add a vote on (after I pointed out nothing else is happening) then you obviously know it’s gonna come to needing to claim lol

True. I mean, gun to my head, I doubt Smark sticks his neck out to save Banez

 

[Evans]

Your premise is completely faulty. Why would discussing a random character (obviously, he is scum so nobody knows he is this character) draw attention to himself? It’s just setup/theme spec lol it’s not drawing attention to himself. The fact he happened to be the character he was discussing is completely irrelevant in this case because he was not admitting to being that character.

here he admitted to not being the main town alignment, after we Lynched somebody that claimed the same alignment and he never even mentioned it. That’s guaranteed to draw attention because people don’t like it when you claim something different to their own alignment

At any point, discussing your character/flavour, even not as a claim like the MJF scenario is going to be a risk and posts around characters/theme spec/set up spec are going to draw attention. Suspicion? Not necessarily, but people will look at those posts, especially from experienced hosts or those with theme knowledge. We’ve already seen those posts this game around the theme knowledge/scum team. Hell, we even discussed it about Ryuk.

That last paragraph isn’t accurate. Smark has claimed the main town alignment and a secondary alignment right after we saw a town player flip the same alignment.

It was never meant to develop into a huge argument. I gave reasonings for my vote on Smark earlier for his claim. I was disputing one point that Smark wouldn’t draw attention to himself as scum and used the AEW game as a “in this situation, he wasn’t afraid to risk that there, I think he’d do the same here”

I don’t buy the claim
I don’t buy the idea that he didn’t look at his PM and completely missed the fact his alignment colour was different to the OP or that Banez claimed someone mentioned in his pm.
I do buy that he dropped that “man I’m that alignment too!” as a juicy WIFOM bomb to try and garner town reads, the ole “Smark wouldn’t risk that as scum”

 

[Lethal]

I kinda have a problem with 3/4 of your scum team being people that were either on banez early or banez was on them early lol. It’s like you’ve not put any thought into it at all

I was working off a theory that I am not withdrawing. I assure you that I did put thought into it, just my thought was misguided.

Also re: OMB i was suss of him from one of his first posts where he wasn't rambling about who was scum, just a vague suss of haza and being non-commital. You having a similar read gave me confidence it wasn't just me tunneling a player who is 'easy' for me to target

 

[Poyser]

Completely disagree that discussing possible scum characters would draw attention. It might indirectly if that’s all you’re doing and not talking about anything game related but that in itself isn’t an attention drawer, sorry. People do it in some capacity almost every game lol

you were on smark before his claim were you not? I think you’re just shoehorning reasons to read him scum here and I’m not convinced it’s above board or you would at least be lending weight to the fact that he literally helped me kick the banez wagon off back when I first started giving banez suspicion and then again when I asked for votes. That’s a very quick decision to bus the motherfucker because he was instantly saying I was making a good case

 

[Lethal]

My answer is meant to say now, not not, fyi

 

[Lethal]

re: Smark/Evans

Is it not normal for people to speculate as to whom the scum characters may be? I know I used it as my crutch in Star Wars and Prison Break to appear productive, but it's also decent to have a bank of data to judge claims from

 

[Poyser]

Are we to assume you don’t have a daykill then lethal?