kwehhh!!
Poyser looks very town to me, his thoughts come across as genuine and also he doesn't feel like opportunistic scum Poyser who I think would have easily forced an early wagon on me. I don't think scum Poyser lets an opportunity like that slide, especially seeing as he even pointed out that he didn't like my vote, like it'd be the easiest thing in the world for him to actually push that as scum.
Not sure how to judge Ace atm cause the thing people seemed to forget during this debate about his entrance is that Ace actually did have some thoughts to share on the first five pages after I asked him about it. It could be that he really entered the thread as scum going "I have absolutely nothing important to say" and then felt he needed to correct as soon as I asked him about it, but overall I still think this is more likely a town entrance from him, not least because it's Ace.
Doddsy also looks town to me, I don't think I've ever seen scum Doddsy actually have an opinion that he's willing to throw into a conversation that didn't concern him personally, especially on a topic as mundane as a single town read from one player on another that he doesn't agree with.
Gambit gets the slightest of town leans for not feeling completely off.
Lethal not voting me like he usually does despite going out of his way to call chocobos toxic (you shall experience a most painful, gruesome death by a thousand chocobos pecking away at you btw) is also noted.
And yeah I also think Banez feels different here. I usually find it easy to read him town off of a handful of posts if he actually is town but this ain't it so far.
vote Banez