Crusader Kings II: A Mafia Tale GAME Thread

[Comrade Khan]

yeah this is all WIFOM lol. Chris was the only confirmed or to-be confirmed town so seems pretty obvious he'd be the kill choice

yeah i think we are more debating why he was blocked ontop. suppose with no other roles exposed it could just be as simple as that fwiw

 

[Tweet]

I have no defense for this if you think I'd kill Chris because he might have shot at me, so if this is the direction, lynch me so you can have info on Tweet.

Even if you're town, which that's still a big IF, how does that make me scum and not simply misguided town?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'd rather wagon poyser, he smells

vote poyser

 

[Tweet]

Also he kept his cards pretty close but somehow I don't think Chris woulda shot me.

 

[Odo]

No, this is twisting things. I voted you to see how you and others would react to it because I wasn’t really a fan of your entrance. When you started playing I liked your posts and gave you a town read and just made a comment about despite the rough start I like you.

You then asked me why would I focus on your entrance when “there was so much other stuff going on” and I said you’d take priority over that (even tho I don’t really think there was much else going on at the time). It all makes perfect sense

I didn’t say ‘so much other stuff’ at all, I said the following:

I’m struggling to grasp that of everything going on, you felt that was the best thing to go with tho?

can some of you guys actively look town pls!

can you see how you’ve completely altered the meaning of what I said lol? My point was that if you felt strong enough to throw it out there as opposed to an active player, I’d expect you to follow up and rally the troops

 

[Smart Marx]

Even if you're town, which that's still a big IF, how does that make me scum and not simply misguided town?

If we're going with the theory one pf us killed Chris cuz they were scared, I know I didn't kill him and I honestly put little faith in you being misguided town with how much you disregard personal experience being scum with me, but I mean it's not 100%.

It'll be up to town to decide as I'll be lynched and won't get a say in how they read you after I flip town.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Also he kept his cards pretty close but somehow I don't think Chris woulda shot me.

explain

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Vote Count:

Poyser (1) - Jeff

 

[Tweet]

explain

Just a feeling, got no evidence for it.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Chris was never getting lynched, pretty simple.

Just a feeling, got no evidence for it.

 

[Smart Marx]

I'd rather wagon poyser, he smells

vote poyser

What are you seeing about Poyser that I'm missing?

Not to mention, don't you believe Tweet or I shot Chris?

 

[Odo]

Also he kept his cards pretty close but somehow I don't think Chris woulda shot me.

I don’t mean this to be nasty, I say it in good humour but when you typed this, did you think it would be persuasive?

 

[Smart Marx]

Also he kept his cards pretty close but somehow I don't think Chris woulda shot me.

I don't think he would have shot me either, but I don't think that argument for either of us is gonna hold up.

 

[CraigPelton]

also I completely forgot about chris being the vig within the last hour somehow which is why I said the kill choice would be interesting lol. don't do drugs jk they're awesome short-term memory is overrated

 

[Tweet]

If we're going with the theory one pf us killed Chris cuz they were scared, I know I didn't kill him and I honestly put little faith in you being misguided town with how much you disregard personal experience being scum with me, but I mean it's not 100%.

It'll be up to town to decide as I'll be lynched and won't get a say in how they read you after I flip town.

I'm not going with that theory tho, Chris claimed vig and was never getting lynched which is all I need to know as far as motive for killing him goes. The apparent roleblock is a seperate issue but I'd argue that if scum got a roleblock, it'd be worth a shot to keep on blocking Chris and trying to portray him as lying about his role.

"I know I didn't kill him" .....sorry I ever pushed you, I instantly believe you.